Originally Posted by
gambit2051
There are retelling's and re-releases. Marvel and DC finally saw the market with Trades (i have been reading them for over 20 years but the selection the past 5 years is light years ahead of how it used to be), but how many more Year Zero Year One etc must we live through????
I mean...DC seems to honestly have NO ORIGINAL IDEAS LEFT. They just reboot the Universe every few years...
Meanwhile over at Marvel, look what Hickman did to the X-Men in just 12 issues! I have been reading X-Men since i could read, almost literally (since I first learned about Comic Books), and I have seen the highs and lows, but the number of Lows since AvX...but it has never had such a major overhaul before that also makes 100% sense in terms of what a Mutant is and working WITH the past to create something completely New while at the same time we have seen it all before. That is what a really good writer can do, they can take an idea like putting all the mutants on an island (yet AGAIN) and make it completely new (they are doing it from a position of strength and they have many new abilities thanks to working with the idea of Evolution. Krakoa plus the Ultimate Universe Utopia runs are fantastic source material for inspiration. I believe that was Brian Wood.) AND he has made Resurrection a built in idea that Xavier has been PLANNING FOR thanks to the reinvention of Moira (House of X #2 was the best single issue of 2019 imo, and one of the best X-Men Comics EVER). Think about how much Inspiration that takes, to actually build upon the previous work, not to reappropriate or steal, but to acknowledge that was a great 1st step now here is the 3rd and 4th steps past that.
I do not see any of that at DC right now (other than Morrison's GL/Darkstars run (Edit: i originally put Moore and knew that had to be wrong, i always get the 2 of them switched bc they are tonally similar and both great writers) and Lobdell's Flash-Forward/Wally West Redemption Series) that feels like it is doing that. Bendis came into the Superman series with a hammer, there was no nuance there, it was just "this is how it is now, deal with it" and I have not enjoyed it. I am still mad about what he has done with Jon and i am positive it is because Bendis does not know how to write kids long-term, so instant age up and destruction of the incredible relationship that Jon had given his powers, place, and personality. Bendis had to change most all of it so that Jon would fit his needs, and the same is said for everything else. I mean Gemworld brings Kon back?
This whole ignore what happened and just write around it approach seems to have been DC's mandate for the ENTIRETY of Rebirth, not just at the beginning when we all expected it.
It makes me appreciate Hickman's FF, Avengers, and now X-Men runs that much more, and look down on writers or editors that decide to just ignore what came before when they take over a Legacy series. There are of course exceptions for time skips and such, but not for Editorial Stupidity like Kords handling in Forever Evil moving forward.
phew, i needed that lol