Geralt of Rivia (The Witcher TV show) vs Captain America (MCU).

[Cleric of Hell’s Brigade]

Scenario 1: Melee weapons only.

Scenario : Magic allowed.


We’ll presume Cap doesn’t have a gun.

Which more than human man wins?

[Beadle]

Does a motorcycle count as a melee weapon for Cap?

And I’m assuming we’re not counting Mjolnir.

[Cleric of Hell’s Brigade]

Does a motorcycle count as a melee weapon for Cap?

And I’m assuming we’re not counting Mjolnir.

Just shield.

[BitVyper]

Cap seems considerably stronger, at least as fast, and... maybe more agile. On the other hand, with Cap only having his shield, there's at least a chance Geralt can get a decisive hit in, so probably like, 8-9/10 for Cap? Magic probably isn't going to change much unless Geralt ends up in a situation where he can fire one of those force blasts directly into Cap's chest at point blank range.

[Nik Hasta]

I agree with BitVyper.

Geralt is a bit of a challenge for Cap but he's not anything he hasn't faced down before. Also, Cap is stupidly difficult to keep down.

[The Arbiter]

Yeah, I agree with others here.

Aside from maaaybe speed, Cap has ever physical advantage. You can argue Geralt's magic plays a big part, but honestly it likely doesn't. Cap has straight up survived direct shots to the torso from Ultron's gravity pulse thingy.