Dark does not mean deep.
I have given it more thought. Let poor Maddy Rest In Peace. Basically she was going to summon demons and unleash them on Krakoa because she felt abandoned. A lot of innocent mutants who had nothing to do with her issues with the X-Men would have gotten killed.
Plus everyone on the Quiet Council is proud of what they accomplished for Krakoa. They don’t want to let someone in who is going to destroy it.
I think the fact that Jean has the OG's Maddie's memories would cause her to vote no as she likely wouldnt consider this version the real deal. She was a psychic entity that had a body altered to look like Jean and was going around doing these horrific things and wanted to wage war on Krakoa wearing Jean's face. Yeah, I dont think Jean would voteyes
Would there even be a personality to upload in a resurrected body? Professor Xavier is using Cerebro to make backup's of Mutant's minds. If Maddie is not technically considered an actual person and is just Jean's clone then doesn't it stand to reason that he wouldn't waste the space storing her imprint. The fact that there was a vote and possibility that they could resurrect her means that he felt the need to make a copy. That to me would be a strong argument that she was in fact a separate entity and not just a clone.
The fact that Cyclops tried to convince them but failed I think implies that he did it with people with whom he has a certain confidence (Like, Scott would not waste time trying to convince Apocalypse, Sinister, Exodus, Shaw or Mystique because he knows what he say it won't affect them in the least).
He would appeal to the people who will listen to him (Magneto, Xavier, Storm, Kitty, Jean, Emma and Kurt).
And yet he did not succeed.
Of course did anyone take her pulse to see if she’s dead? This is comics. Plus Arrako’s demons are introduced.
Maddie, Bloodstorm and Evan deserve better.
This outcome affected me more than I expected. Considering she's a complete nut who was planning bloody genocide I'm surprised at how sad I am that she and Havok don't get the same happy ending that all the other Mutants do on Krakoa.
Poor Maddy. I hope we see her again.