Choose 5 DC movies to exist

[MRP]

Batman: Mask of the Phantasm (1993)
Superman (1978)
Superman II (1980)
Superman Returns (2006)
Wonder Woman (2017)

I would have picked Mask of the Phantasm in my 5, except the OP specified live action movies, so I didn't choose any animated features.

-M

[Osiris-Rex]

Superman '78
Batman Returns
Wonder Woman
Aquaman
Suicide Squad

[cgh]

In no particular order:

1. A History of Violence (based on the 1997 Vertigo title)
2. The Dark Knight
3. Joker
4. Superman ‘78
5. Watchmen

[Vakanai]

Superman
Superman 2
Batman
Batman Returns
The Dark Knight

Honorable mention: Joker

[Gurz]

1- Superman The Movie
2- Superman II
3- Superman III
4- Superman IV
5- Batman 89

[Vakanai]

3- Superman III
4- Superman IV

Hoping MST3K tackles those films one day, or is there a drinking game here I don't know about?

[Stromberg]

Birds of Prey
Wonder Woman
Batman v Superman
Batman Returns
Justice League

[Bored at 3:00AM]

Superman The Movie - Still the gold standard for DC superhero movies and the template that the MCU used to completely dominate the box office. The Donner Cut of Superman II is also great, but it's not really a finished film, nor will it ever be outside of my imagination.

Batman Returns - This is a deeply twisted film, but it is easily the most compelling Batman and Catwoman that have ever been put to film. Nicholson's Joker is way better than Devito's Penguin, but this is the superior Batman film in terms of ambition, style and fun.

Wonder Woman - Despite the disappointing 3rd act, Gadot & Pine are just so f&^%ing good and have so much chemistry that it doesn't matter. This is the depiction of Wonder Woman in any media by a wide margin. That's not exactly a deep pool, but still.

Green Lantern - A deeply flawed film, but is also so chock full of awesome ideas and visuals that I think it's more rewatchable than the superior, but pretentious Nolan films. Aquaman almost had this spot, and is pretty much the same movie beat for beat, but I'm simply more of a goofy cosmic nonsense fan than a goofy underwater nonsense fan.

Man of Steel & Batman vs Superman *Director's Cut* - These two films are one big film in my mind that are, again, deeply flawed, but features some of the best visuals that the superhero genre has ever seen. While they are largely maligned, the visual flair that these films brought to superhero films was deeply influential and forced Marvel Studios to up its game.

[HunterX]

Green Arrow
Black Canary & Green Arrow
Arsenal
Firestorm
Blue beetle & Cyborg

[Koriand'r]

Superman II
Batman Returns
Suicide Squad
Watchmen
Aquaman

[Vakanai]

Green Arrow
Black Canary & Green Arrow
Arsenal
Firestorm
Blue beetle & Cyborg

It's choose 5 already existing films to still exist I think, not 5 films you wish existed.

[maxmcco]

Shazam
Wonder Woman
Batman Returns
Superman the Movie
Man of Steel

[superduperman]

Superman 4
Batman & Robin
Jonah Hex
Green Lantern
Suicide Squad

[Vakanai]

Superman 4
Batman & Robin
Jonah Hex
Green Lantern
Suicide Squad

I don't like the company you're associating Suicide Squad with...