In your opinion, make a list of all of the major Robins (Grayson, Todd, Drake, Brown, and Wayne) to rank them in preference. Elseworld or out of continuity Robins do not count.
In your opinion, make a list of all of the major Robins (Grayson, Todd, Drake, Brown, and Wayne) to rank them in preference. Elseworld or out of continuity Robins do not count.
Is this list supposed to be limited to stuff done while Robin or does it include everything post Robin too?
Grayson, Drake, Wayne, Todd, then Brown.
Pulls: Batman, Detective Comics, SiKtC, Catwoman, Nightwing, Titans, Godzilla, Wonder Woman, Batman & Robin, Brave and the Bold, No/One, Kill your Darlings, and Deviant.
My runs: Batman #230-, and Detective #420-
Easy question:
1 — Dick Grayson
2 — Jason Todd
3 — Damian Wayne
4 — Stephanie Brown
For me it would be:
1. Dick Grayson
2. Damian Wayne
3. Jason Todd
4. Tim Drake
5. Stephanie Brown (although if I were counting her Batgirl run I would put her above Tim)
1. Dick
2. Damian
>>>>>
3. Steph
4. Jason
5. Tim
Carrie would bump down Steph as a distant third if she was included.
Hasnt this question been asked and polled several times?
Anyway
1. Tim
2. Dick
3. Damian
4. Jason
Wayne
Grayson
Drake and Todd [I haven't read much Jason as Robin to be honest but he's big on charisma so rank him equal with Tim despite Tim 's extensive library of stories]
Brown
Last edited by CPSparkles; 03-11-2019 at 06:08 PM.
1. Richard Grayson - Good time as Robin, but excellent post Robin for what he was able to expand and explore when he left the role. He created a superhero standard for the following gens.
2. Tim Drake - Had a great time as Robin and still continues to be Robin and elevating the standards of the role.
3. Jason Todd - Has his ups and downs. Horrible Robin, great Red Hood but still needs to mature more before he can reach Grayson status.
4. Damian Wayne - Close to the same strength and intelligence level as the other Robins at such a young age but the problem is his instability and overall, he's a Robin that you couldn't trust completely in your team. Haven't seen his future alternative version where he isn't a mad version of Batman following a diluted version of Bruce's original goal.
1. Jason Todd
2. Damian Wayne
3. Dick Grayson
4. Stephanie Brown
5. Carrie Kelly
6. Matt McGinnis
7. Tim Drake
Just as Robin
1. Tim Drake
2. Dick Grayson
3. Damian Wayne
4. Jason Todd
5. Stephanie Brown
If we include everything/(Not looking at them just in the role of Robin)
1. Dick Grayson
2. Jason Todd
3. Damian Wayne(would be higher if certain writers wouldn't regress his character development so frequently, the potential is there)
4. Tim/Steph tied for 4th/5th. Both have had some really good stretches of writing, and some really bad ones. The reboot really hurt these two.