Golden Age DC Big Three vs. Golden and Silver Age Marvel Big Three

[Supergoblin64]

Golden Age Superman, Batman, and Wonder Woman vs. Silver Age Mark I Iron Man and Thor and Golden Age Captain America

Feats can only be used from the first two or three years of each characters' existence. No prep on either side.

Who wins?

[Beadle]

I think early Thor is probably breaking the power curve here.

[Captain Morgan]

Yeah my understanding is Thor was pretty powerful from the get go. Arguably stronger in his original stories, in fact. Or at least Asgardians ranked higher on the cosmic ladder.

[The Arbiter]

I agree with the other posters here. Early Thor was pretty beastly right away.

I have a few old Thor comics playing around somewhere. I'll flip through them tonight.

[LifeIsILL]

It all depends on if early Wonder Woman was as powerful as Thor....I doubt it though.

And Batman?? LOL Early Batman was getting beat up by regular hoodlums...come on...

[Slade1]

What feats do we have for Golden Age Superman?

[Captain Morgan]

What feats do we have for Golden Age Superman?

I think that depends on where the golden age becomes the silver age, really.

[Beadle]

I think that depends on where the golden age becomes the silver age, really.

But not in this case, given that we’re limited to the first three years.

[Captain Morgan]

But not in this case, given that we’re limited to the first three years.

Yup, missed that bit.

[big_adventure]

Yup, in his first two dozen issues Thor was smacking around Ego, manipulating time, etc.

[Powerboy]

What feats do we have for Golden Age Superman?

Well within three years, the GA Superman was leaping to the edge of the atmosphere. But that's small potatoes compared to Thor. He was pulverizing small planets and holding his own against Galactus, this being before they solidly established the hierarchy and more or less assumed the gods couldn't be second best at least by much.