Should Wanda Maximoff (Scarlet Witch stand trial for House of M ?

[GenericUsername]

Sue Richards also trusted that same villain and so has the X-Men. It's not strawman to point out the hypocrisy and sexism in some of the hateful comments. You just don't like being confronted with that.

Wanda being rewritten to resent mutants was terrible.

It's canon that she didn't know what was going on or how to stop it and completely lost her memory.

The amount of deaths flucuated so much that no one really knows the exact number. Because it wasn't important to writers.

Wanda was remorseful at first. It didn't matter anyway. Nothing could make up for it. Marvel botched redemption for drama. Because pissing off X-fans is easy and fun for them.

Again, don't be mad when people point out the similarities. Wanda doesn't exist in the universe alone. And there are very few heroes without some evil arc these days.

[LordAllMIghty]

It barely killed people

Since the spell effect the entire multiverse, if one mutant was killed on 616 earth then she still killed an infinite amounts of mutants.

Also, there no such thing as barely killed.

[darkalamator]

The Scarlet Witch is basically a Murderess Monster. She remains unaccountable and showing no remorse whatsoever of the lifes she took and wrecked. Typical genocide psicopath behaviour. If Mutankind really wants to be treated like any other State on Earth they must insisit she faces trial where the genocides face trial. The Hague. Will the Avengers be so arrogant as to think themselves above the Law? That would expose them to the world as criminals, no heroes. Is MU a world where the Law does not exist? where "superheroes" do not face accuntability? Will Iron Man stand for the Scarlet Witch after all the Civil Wars bla bla bla he went through?

[useridgoeshere]

people need to get over this

I agree with you. The character should be left in X-limbo (and not the good Illyana kind). You've got a 1960's character that's mostly been a plot-convenience with only three memorable stories over all that time - Darker the Scarlet, Decimation, and House of M. No writer beyond Byrne and Bendis have ever successfully elevated or made any other story better by including the character. If they want to mention the character as a part of Krakoan myth, like Satan, Lucifer or Freddie Krueger, that's the most they should do.

[spirit2011]

Since the spell effect the entire multiverse, if one mutant was killed on 616 earth then she still killed an infinite amounts of mutants.

Also, there no such thing as barely killed.

the spell was for depower, not to kill mutants, very few would die from it. it is impossible to affect all multiverse

I agree with you. The character should be left in X-limbo (and not the good Illyana kind). You've got a 1960's character that's mostly been a plot-convenience with only three memorable stories over all that time - Darker the Scarlet, Decimation, and House of M. No writer beyond Byrne and Bendis have ever successfully elevated or made any other story better by including the character. If they want to mention the character as a part of Krakoan myth, like Satan, Lucifer or Freddie Krueger, that's the most they should do.

This isn't fair, look how many x-men did bad things and how many villains are on the island

[GenericUsername]

I agree with you. The character should be left in X-limbo (and not the good Illyana kind). You've got a 1960's character that's mostly been a plot-convenience with only three memorable stories over all that time - Darker the Scarlet, Decimation, and House of M. No writer beyond Byrne and Bendis have ever successfully elevated or made any other story better by including the character. If they want to mention the character as a part of Krakoan myth, like Satan, Lucifer or Freddie Krueger, that's the most they should do.

None of that is true. Those were infamous stories but not Hallmarks for her. Nights of Wundagore, Vision and the Scarlet Witch, her solos, Busiek's run were all great moments for the character and what her fans enjoy. Just because people are bitter doesn't mean there are magically a lack of stories. It just means there's an obsession about the character complete with blinders about anything else that doesn't project a certain narrative.

[GenericUsername]

The Scarlet Witch is basically a Murderess Monster. She remains unaccountable and showing no remorse whatsoever of the lifes she took and wrecked. Typical genocide psicopath behaviour. If Mutankind really wants to be treated like any other State on Earth they must insisit she faces trial where the genocides face trial. The Hague. Will the Avengers be so arrogant as to think themselves above the Law? That would expose them to the world as criminals, no heroes. Is MU a world where the Law does not exist? where "superheroes" do not face accuntability? Will Iron Man stand for the Scarlet Witch after all the Civil Wars bla bla bla he went through?

Iron Man has had his own problems with villainy. So much so that he's been completely replaced. With a teen version of himself. Now his AI version might be doing villainous stuff. People act like this hasn't happened to just about everyone in the universe by now.

[nandes]

it is impossible to affect all multiverse

Not exactly the multiverse, but in Messiah Complex, Forge reveals that all possible futures in that mutants existed were affected.

[GenericUsername]

Yeah... the problem is that they are about as consistent with that as they were with continuity to create M-day and fridge Wanda.

[LordAllMIghty]

the spell was for depower, not to kill mutants, very few would die from it. it is impossible to affect all multiverse

Almost 100% sure the spell effect the multiverse.

[spirit2011]

Not exactly the multiverse, but in Messiah Complex, Forge reveals that all possible futures in that mutants existed were affected.

possible futures i smore believable than infinite earths as it would need a infinite source of power

[LordAllMIghty]

possible futures i smore believable than infinite earths as it would need a infinite source of power

What makes you think it doesn't have an infinite source of power?

Also, is that Forge or Tony Stark? Just notice how similar they look. Lol

Edit. Just read OP comments. Lol

[GenericUsername]

What makes you think it doesn't have an infinite source of power?

Also, is that Forge or Tony Stark? Just notice how similar they look. Lol

Edit. Just read OP comments. Lol

We really don't have canon proof of the extent of the life force outside of this story. Because it was only used before very vaguely in the stories about elder gods. But it's also not consistent in this story either. So you just have to wait for there to be some official, consistent definition for it. And that might not ever happen. It and Wanda were just Macguffins for the story. It wasn't meant to be flushed out.

It'd be one of the problems with a trial.

[CoCoBandz]

Part of her punishment should be to attend every crucible and rebirth of all the Mutants she maimed.

[GenericUsername]

Part of her punishment should be to attend every crucible and rebirth of all the Mutants she maimed.

She likely would. She wanted to repower them herself. That was refused by Scott.