Worst Rumble YOU Ever Posted

[KJS]

What's the worst rumble you ever posted?

Maybe you didn't quite understand the differences in power scale between two different universes at the time. Maybe you didn't understand how the rules on this forum operate. Maybe you just didn't know enough about one of/both of the participants in your rumble.

For me, for example, when I first joined the previous forum back in 2003/4, I posted "Illyria Vs The Silver Surfer".

This was before Angel Season 6, so Illyria didn't even have her comic book feats (and that match would still be a stomp even if she did). I wanted to know if Amy Acker's TV portrayal of Illyria could take on the comic book Silver Surfer, because she was arguably the most powerful thing in the Buffyverse at the time, so - at least I thought - she MUST be able to hang with Marvel's big guns.

How wrong I was and how much I've learned here!

So what's yours?

[The Arbiter]

My 2nd thread ever was quite literally "Killer Croc vs. The Lizard". That went poorly.

My 4th or 5th thread ever was "Kerrigan vs. Wonder Woman". That was a hot mess. You should have seen me try and defend that one lol. I was at one point arguing it would be a close fight because "it would look cool!". :P

My other earliest threads included "Master Chief vs. Samus" and "Akuma vs. Raiden" and so forth.

Edit: this was back in 2004 I think.

[Dark Soul # 7]

At one point I posted a fight between two Draculas.

One of them was the Dracula from Marvel comics who has made fair efforts in fighting guys like classic Dr. Strange and Silver Surfer.

The other Dracula was the one from the Hugh Jackman movie Van Helsing.

Yeah... that one got all the ridicule it deserved.

[Jcogginsa]

IIRC I once posted "Bruce Lee vs. Sanji"

[Beadle]

I’ve usually shied away from starting Rumbles, but I do remember a period of trying to find a decent match-up for Count Nefaria.

And failing.

Often.

[KJS]

I’ve usually shied away from starting Rumbles, but I do remember a period of trying to find a decent match-up for Count Nefaria.

And failing.

Often.

If it makes you feel any better, "2004 me" would've put him against Rupert Giles or something.

[Froggy]

I think it was sonic related?