Who we think is best suited as Peter's partner, or who we like the most as Peter's partner? They're two different things. Are we strictly talking present day? What if someone would vote Gwen, but doesn't want her to be brought back to life?
Felicia and no other
Felicia followed by Gwen and no other
Felicia followed by MJ and no other
Felicia followed by MJ and Gwen (in that order)
Felicia followed by Gwen and MJ (in that order)
MJ and no other
MJ followed by Felcia and no other
MJ followed by Gwen and no other
MJ followed by Felcia and Gwen (in that order)
MJ followed by Gwen and Felicia (in that order)
Gwen and no other
Gwen followed by Felcia and no other
Gwen followed by MJ and no other
Gwen followed by Felcia and MJ (in that order)
Gwen followed by MJ and Felcia (in that order)
Who we think is best suited as Peter's partner, or who we like the most as Peter's partner? They're two different things. Are we strictly talking present day? What if someone would vote Gwen, but doesn't want her to be brought back to life?
For most people, it would be the same thing, but you're right, it's not. Without indulging too much in something so academic, I'd say that "fits you better" equals "who you like most" for our purposes.
We're talking about the character's history, past and present. If you liked it better with someone who's no longer around, you still liked it better. I leave the future outside the purview of these polls.
I know the fans of Felicia, Mary Jones, someone else, no one, and ( especially) Gwen, will not like this: The answer on both best fit and who I prefer is Mary Jane: I acknowledge, she is far from perfect ( ASM 87 “ You can have him to Gwen” and abandoning her sister). That is Especially true because Aunt May who raised Peter chose her ( for reasons I do not need to rehash).
Carlie Cooper is the one Peter was most compatible with. Pete really screwed up there.
I much prefer Mary Jane over Felicia. Felicia don’t really commit to the relationship. Besides, didn’t she freaked out when spider-man took of his mask? She only loves spider-man, not the person behind the mask.
I haven't been following the Black Cat solo, but is she romantically tied to anyone? I think it would be nice if more writers explored her bisexuality. A little more LGBTQ+ representation in the Spider-man corner of the MU wouldn't hurt.