Originally Posted by
Digifiend
I kind of agree there. New 52 (which would obviously be called something else, let's say DC Prime, due to the reality being called Prime Earth) should've been like the Ultimate Universe (and be named accordingly). A dozen titles showing new origins, while the majority of the old line continues. The books I have in mind are Superman, Batman, Teen Titans, Justice League, Wonder Woman, Green Lantern, Aquaman, Flash, Batgirl, Superboy, Shazam, and Earth-2. They'd be pretty much as happened in New 52 (for the first couple of years anyway, before old stuff started getting reintroduced such as the extended bat family) with a couple of exceptions - for example, Batgirl wouldn't need an implant to walk, because she was never crippled, Killing Joke never happened. Green Lantern is the one book that would not be what happened in New 52, that would instead be the New Earth GL story, and DC Prime Green Lantern would reboot one of them (the reason for this is that GL never really rebooted in New 52).
There'd be a big contrast in some books. DC Prime Batgirl would be Babs, New Earth Batgirl would still be Stephanie Brown. DC Prime Green Lantern would be one hero's origin, New Earth GL would feature the Corps. Teen Titans and Justice League would use different lineups in the two universes. Robin would be Dick Grayson in Prime (Tim would still exist, but as Red Robin, meaning New 52 TT is unaffected), but Damian Wayne in the old continuity.