Did the Bendis All new X-men go back to their time?

[Hol]

I think it's also worth pointing out that it was shown with adult Cyclops' appearance in Champions that the adult versions of O5 now have the memories of their time traveling counterparts.

How would that work though if even they don't have their memories? Didn't Jean wipe them when they returned?

[Cyke]

That’s Hickman right? I’m not a big Hickman fan but I do miss the X-men. Is it better than his Avengers?

I loved his Avengers, but tbh I didn't appreciate it fully until I could binge-read it. Getting them in monthly doses, to me, kind of diluted the pace. I expect the same out of Dawn of X, but I'm also here for the ride.

How would that work though if even they don't have their memories? Didn't Jean wipe them when they returned?

Wibbly-wobbly, timey-wimey.

(plus, it's not unprecedented for telepathy in Marvel to not obey temporal physics. Cable used to be a slight precog different than Destiny because of that. White Phoenix Jean was able to communicate to the past and thus reach out to another universe before its branching point. So yeah, wibbly-wobbly, timey-wimey.)

[Odd Rödney]

White Phoenix Jean was able to communicate to the past

Didn't Rachel use something similar in the recent X-Factor #1? I can't remember specifically what she did but it was something to do with detecting what had happened in a room in the past or something.

[Harpsikord]

Didn't Rachel use something similar in the recent X-Factor #1? I can't remember specifically what she did but it was something to do with detecting what had happened in a room in the past or something.

Part of Rachel and Jean's powers is psychometry, it isn't used very often. Rachel's goes a little deeper and she doesn't have to look at time linearly or anything similar.

How would that work though if even they don't have their memories? Didn't Jean wipe them when they returned?

Jean had them specifically locked until the moment that the O5 went back in the past. When they got back to the past, adult Jean remembered how to stop the Hounds because teen Jean figured it out due to Maxime and Manon telling teen Jean. It was made clear at the end of Extermination that they had their memories.

[Hol]

Part of Rachel and Jean's powers is psychometry, it isn't used very often. Rachel's goes a little deeper and she doesn't have to look at time linearly or anything similar.



Jean had them specifically locked until the moment that the O5 went back in the past. When they got back to the past, adult Jean remembered how to stop the Hounds because teen Jean figured it out due to Maxime and Manon telling teen Jean. It was made clear at the end of Extermination that they had their memories.

Thanks! I appreciate it. Just getting caught up here.

[Odd Rödney]

Part of Rachel and Jean's powers is psychometry, it isn't used very often. Rachel's goes a little deeper and she doesn't have to look at time linearly or anything similar.

That's it, thanks! I never would've remembered that word.