I just randomly had this thought as I read through "The Name of the Rose" (Web of Spider-Man #84-89) story. I haven't seen too many good things said about this one, but under all of the ridiculousness of it, I still found myself enjoying it. A lot of the characters (Peter included) behaved very strangely, though I believe that was the main thing that kept me reading.

Sins Past is another one. I can understand why a lot of people were turned off by this one, though. It also probably helps that I wasn't much of a Gwen Stacy fan back when I first read it, so it didn't really leave me feeling the same way as longtime fans felt.

I understand that "bad" is subjective, but are there any stories that you've enjoyed that many others disliked?