he was found, in the court case he demanded, to the required standard of balance of probabilities (with the higher threshold because of the seriousness of the claims) to have:
1. Assaulted Heard for mocking his tattoos.
2. Assaulted Heard for having a painting from an ex.
3. Assaulted Heard in a trailer.
4. Assaulted Heard on the plane.
5. Assaulted Heard while she was trying to help him detox in the Bahamas.
6. Assaulted Heard during a stay in Tokyo.
7. Assaulted Heard during the stay in Australia, also having done what is alleged in a sealed confidential docket, and that his much publicised finger wounds were self-inflicted.
8. Assaulted Heard on the stairs, during which time Heard hit him in self-defence.
9. Assaulted Heard on the train in SE Asia.
10. Assaulted Heard prior to the Late Late Show.
11. Assaulted Heard during the birthday, Heard didn’t abuse him as claimed, and that it was the dog that shat the bed (judge clearly annoyed at that being repeatedly raised in the courtroom).
12. Assaulted Heard in LA in 2016, also heavily criticises the LAPD for having no notes of incident and lying about the time they were there.
Commanilty noted in these claims were his jealously, anger issues, and problems with drink and drugs.
The only two incidents that didn’t pass the probabilities also note that the judge is careful with the language, with the allegation in LA of 2014 not found due to a lack of specificity in what was claimed to have happened and therefore could’ve just been a charged verbal incident that Depp was apologising for and the allegation in LA of 2015 was “not proven” as Depp hadn’t been cross-examined on it.
So again, this was a case Depp called for in the UK because it’s easier to win here, when previously it was perceived by many (inc. myself I will admit) as allegations both ways and that both sounded similarly abusive, and now it’s gone to material trial and fell apart almost immediately as his case was made up of substantial contradictions, falsehoods, and just about zero impartial witnesses while Heard’s account was backed up.