We could get an even worse group together. This one is actually a little hampered by people like Mablung and, in a straight-up fight, Beren (due to lack of decent armor in his standard kit, not skill or feats, because he's perfectly capable of physically beating all hell out of high-end Noldor with his bare hands).
Also, Beren doesn't have his wife with him.
Edit: You know what's funny? We don't have Galadriel in this group, either. I mean, she was around and active in the First Age, being Third Age Noldor just like Finrod (her brother). She just doesn't turn up a lot, mostly because she was hanging out in Doriath with Melian and Lúthian, and they kind of eclipsed her.
...you don't hear that phrase often used wrt Galadriel, but there it is.