Originally Posted by
SecretWarrior
I would've made John Stewart the central GL back in '01 or '02, when the Justice League show was on. He would serve on Earth, while Kyle and Guy would be honor guard. A lot of this would be John readjusting to Earth after multiple tours of duty in space. Symbolizing John's connection to the planet would be a new love interest he had some prior history with. After fleshing John out a bit, I would do Sinestro Corp War, with Hal Jordan returning as Parallax for the first time since his last Parallax appearance, meaning no Specter phase. Thaal would still be the leader of the SC. At the end of SCW, Hal would redeem himself a la Darth Vader. Then I would do a version of Rebirth where the story would be set on Oa, with Atrocitus using Manhunters to assault the Guardians and Honor Guard, ultimately failing to destroy the Corp, but releasing SC captives and destroying Oa. The universe would be policed by the three factions for a bit. Hal would get some approval from the Corp, but still be distrusted by the Darkstar Lanterns. The GLC would move onto Mogo. A side plot involving Black Hand would eventually culminate in the dead from Thaal's tyrannical rule rising from the grave and destroying the SC, leaving the sectors they took over in disarray. Some French revolution imagery here. The GLs would fight Atrocitus for the Yellow battery on a zombie infested planet, with Hal having to become Parallax again to prevent them from acquiring the entity. Atrocitus and the Manhunters would leave for fontier space, leaving the GLC and JL as the only factions to take on the threat and restore order. Black Hand would revive the Anti-Monitor to wipe out all life. John makes a deal with Darkseid, knowing that Apocalypse will try to betray the good guys to get BH's powers, sold as the Anti-life equation. The New Gods would help the heroes to boom tube BH and the Anti-Monitor into the Anti-Matter universe while Darkseid and Parallax hold them off, to Darkseid's surprise at getting betrayed himself. John's arc would center around whether or not he's the chosen one in a GL prophecy (Tower of Talo) or Hal is, with both having undertaken actions that saved the universe-- kind of like Anakin vs Luke. To play this up, there would be questions about whether Abin's ring was supposed to go to John, but Hal was closer, causing the Guardians to manufacture a situation leading to John becoming the GL. The answer would ultimately b ambiguous, with a message about prophecies being mostly self-fulfilling. In the end, John turns down an offer to be the first human Guardian in order to start a family on Earth with his love interest. Kyle would become a Guardian instead, and Guy would work alongside a new inductee to the Honor Guard, like Arisia Raab.