Negan vs Billy Butcher

[JohnDiggle]

Tv show versions. Who wins? Hand to hand, bat to crow bar.

[Beadle]

The ex-SAS guy (IIRC) who gets into melee fights with supes beats the guy who stumbles about factories brawling with Rick Grimes.

If it were a promo contest, my money would be on Negan. But it’s not.

[The Chou Lives]

Butcher.

Began was a high school gym coach before the zombies.

Bill was already killing people in the army and got better since.

[master of read]

as much as i love negan, bill takes it.

[MichaelC]

Glen is avenged at last!

[The Chou Lives]

Glen is avenged at last!

Yeah Negan survives the comic, lost interest in the show.

Here?

Billy: Hey cunt, think your tough huh? : dodge bat, disarms him.: “
Going to shove this up your ass, barbs and all.”

[numberthirty]

Negan's entire bit is not having to be able to win a fight.

Can he do a semi-pro job of leading a group of zombie killers? Sure.

Take Butcher in a right where Butcher has a crowbar, and he has a wooden baseball bat? Probably not going to happen.

[big_adventure]

The only question is whether Butcher says "diabolical" before or after shoving Negan's bat up where the sun doesn't shine.

[The Chou Lives]

Negan's entire bit is not having to be able to win a fight.

Can he do a semi-pro job of leading a group of zombie killers? Sure.

Take Butcher in a right where Butcher has a crowbar, and he has a wooden baseball bat? Probably not going to happen.

Book Negan:

It is shameful Negan was only better at fighting Rick, because Rick had only one fucking hand.

But against zombies? He is a murder machine with that bat and could direct orders, why he got power.

Show Negan: He had a fight club style fight to the death when o e of his followers did something he did not approve of, won it fair and square ( hand to hand.)

But yeah show Butcher still wins. Army fighter and nesses up multiple normal
Dudes regularly.