Rank these characters!

[master of read]

popeye should be higher on the list. at least higher than king kong. the dude has beaten things way bigger than kong, in seconds.

[Jcogginsa]

popeye should be higher on the list. at least higher than king kong. the dude has beaten things way bigger than kong, in seconds.

Would you have him higher than Kratos/The Thing?

[master of read]

Would you have him higher than Kratos/The Thing?

popeye regularly punches shit that shouldn't even be possible to punch, like magic, hypnosis and music notes. as someone else noted, popeye doesn't just hit hard. he actively warps reality with the sheer power of his punches.

so yeah. he's well above kratos and ben.

[Jcogginsa]

popeye regularly punches shit that shouldn't even be possible to punch, like magic, hypnosis and music notes. as someone else noted, popeye doesn't just hit hard. he actively warps reality with the sheer power of his punches.

so yeah. he's well above kratos and ben.

Can't really quantify that as a strength feat though.

Course, Popeye does have feats that can be quantified. I can recall at least too occasions where he punched a dude to the opposite side of the country, and one where he punched someone around the world

[Jcogginsa]

Revised list 5

1. Thanos
2. The Hulk
3. Thor
4. Darkseid
5. Superman
6. Wonder Woman
7. Goku
8. Hal Jodan
9. Invincible
10. Lex Luthor
11. Sun Wukong
12. Akuma
13. Godzilla
14. Buttercup Utonium
15. Blossom Utonium
16. Bubbles Utonium
17. Gamera
18. Aquaman
19. Savage Dragon
20. Ultraman Belial
21. Ultraman
22. Naruto Uzumaki
23. Popeeye the Sailor Man*
24. Monkey D. Luffy
25. Astro Boy
26. The Thing
27. Sonic the Hedgehog**
28. Kratos
29. Iron Man
30. Dr. Doom
31. King Kong
32. RX-78 Gundam
33. Kenshiro
34. Optimus Prime
35. Spider-Man
36. Ben 10
37. Megamind (with Super Suit on.)
38. Mario
39. Steven Universe
40. Samurai Jack
41. Pikachu
42. Po the Panda
43. Stitch
44. Spawn
45. Master Chief
46. Asterix
47. Ruby Rose
48. Samus Aran
49. Scrooge McDuck
50. Tommy Oliver ***
51. Alucard****
52. Sephiroth
53. Loki
54. The Iron Giant
55. The Terminator
56. Robocop
57. Raphael
58. Leonardo
59. Michelangelo
60. Donatello
61. Captain America
62. Solid Snake
63. Guts the Black Swordsman
64. Shrek
65. Conan the Barbarian
66. Hellboy
67. Gru
68. Link
69. Wally West
70. Star Butterfly
71. Buffy Summers
72. Rapunzel
73. Batman
74. Jason Voorhees
75. Freddy Kruger*****
76. Avatar Aang
77. Judge Dredd
78. Xena
79. The Undertaker
80. Spock
81. The Doctor
82. Magneto
83. Imhotep
84. Rick Sanchez
85. Geralt of Rivia
86. Cordell Walker
87. Harry Potter ******
88. Eliott Spencer
89. The Joker
90. Elsa
91. Sherlock Holmes
92. James Bond
93. John Constantine


* Popeye has "Punch a dude for large number of miles" feats just like Luffy does, so putting them on par with each other seems logical to me.

** Not really comfortable with this one. I tried looking for a respect thread for Archie Sonic, but few bothered to discuss his strength in any detail. One of them claimed he was lifted 100+ tons, without a citation, so I based it on that, but If anyone knows more about Archie Sonic, please let me know where a more appropriate placement for him is.

*** Tommy is here because he was able to kick back a rock thrown by a monster who could lift a two ton car. Him being above Alucard just feels wrong though.

**** Stuck Alucard here on basis of him overpowering dandy man's card with his hand.

***** Could not find a decent respect thread for Freddy, so all I really have to go on is that he's not as strong as Jason

****** Logic here is his ability to hold onto his rapidly accelerating broom.

[big_adventure]

Goku kind of has to be number 1, doesn't he? Him in a punch-up with Beerus is mod-ruled as a universal threat, and that's 3 forms below his strongest AND before a crapton of training.

Current Thor has to be higher than Hulk and likely higher than Thanos: he's all-father and he smashed Bill's Uru+enchanted hammer like a cheap plastic kid's toy.

You have Loki WAAAAAAY too low. Dude's at least class 50 or so, overpowering Classic Rogue and such.

[master of read]

Goku kind of has to be number 1, doesn't he? Him in a punch-up with Beerus is mod-ruled as a universal threat, and that's 3 forms below his strongest AND before a crapton of training.

Current Thor has to be higher than Hulk and likely higher than Thanos: he's all-father and he smashed Bill's Uru+enchanted hammer like a cheap plastic kid's toy.

You have Loki WAAAAAAY too low. Dude's at least class 50 or so, overpowering Classic Rogue and such.

well he was also a herald at that point as well, so he was really juiced up at that point. not sure if he is still on the PC since he merc'd galen, though.

[Cthulhu_of_R'lyeh]

Goku kind of has to be number 1, doesn't he? Him in a punch-up with Beerus is mod-ruled as a universal threat, and that's 3 forms below his strongest AND before a crapton of training.

Current Thor has to be higher than Hulk and likely higher than Thanos: he's all-father and he smashed Bill's Uru+enchanted hammer like a cheap plastic kid's toy.

You have Loki WAAAAAAY too low. Dude's at least class 50 or so, overpowering Classic Rogue and such.

Current Thor also killed a Galactus that wasn't starving.

[master of read]

Current Thor also killed a Galactus that wasn't starving.

and jacked up from some uber planets.

[big_adventure]

well he was also a herald at that point as well, so he was really juiced up at that point. not sure if he is still on the PC since he merc'd galen, though.

I think that he actually was NOT herald at the moment he smashed Stormbreaker. Big G had sucked out the PC because he didn't have the patience for the "family squabble."

It was after that where Thor went up and sucked the PC back out of Galactus, against Galactus' wishes. Making it a feat that's not exactly easy to use, as it's generally beyond what Odinforce-power can achieve.

[master of read]

I think that he actually was NOT herald at the moment he smashed Stormbreaker. Big G had sucked out the PC because he didn't have the patience for the "family squabble."

It was after that where Thor went up and sucked the PC back out of Galactus, against Galactus' wishes. Making it a feat that's not exactly easy to use, as it's generally beyond what Odinforce-power can achieve.

i went back and read it.

big G tried to suck it back but thor lolnope'd it. and since he was still in his herald outfit, he still had the PC.

[Dark Soul # 7]

That's cool and all, but man... I'd wish Marvel would jobbing Galactus all the time.

[Beadle]

That's cool and all, but man... I'd wish Marvel would jobbing Galactus all the time.

It’s literally all he’s there for.

He’s the Big Show of the Marvel Universe.

[master of read]

It’s literally all he’s there for.

He’s the Big Show of the Marvel Universe.

well, considering he flip flops between being good and bad..........that's a pretty accurate analogy.

[big_adventure]

i went back and read it.

big G tried to suck it back but thor lolnope'd it. and since he was still in his herald outfit, he still had the PC.

OK, but Thor fought Bill without the herald hair and eyes? No Ultra Instinct?