Originally Posted by
T51R
True, so let's maybe start placing them.
Amagami(my favourite by far, he has so many levels and sides to him) is very complex. Since his style is based on real fighting, he needs to go into sort of that field of opponents. Which probably means he can fit with people from:
-Holyland manga, where he'd probably rule the roost with his actual warfighting experience.
-The Punisher, but he would be a mid to low tier villain at best, since Frank is a damned monster.
-Robin villain, which is about as far as he gets in the Batbooks. Bruce would hang him out to dry in seconds.
-Karate Baka Isekai. I think this would be a good fight, since Amagami would be up against a smart Karate user who has a crapload of experience and a bigger arsenal of techniques.
-Kengan. He has what it takes to definitely be a strong competitor to say Imai, Adam or even maybe even Ryuki. Koga he would still the floor with. No way he gets near someone like Ohma or worse, Kanoh or Akoya.
-Baki. He fits solidly with "the weaker ones," people like Motobe and Gaia. Would LOVE to see a fight between Amagami and Gaia, since it would be the buffet if dirty tricks.
Shinobu would be below that IMO mostly because he doesn't have experience and, at this point, he also has a one-track mind. In an ideal world he would want to go and experience the real battlefield, but doing that would hurt his character since he would probably lose his innocence. So maybe he can fit with:
-Pre-timeskip Baki, before fought with Yujiro the first time.
-Fullmetal Panic's Sousuke Sagara(assuming Sousuke isn't taking things too seriously, or Shinobu won't make it out alive)
-Again, Holyland. Shinobu would be right at home here.
-Baki. He'd probably be able to study under Doppo or Shibukawa. Because he sure as hell isn't beating them.