Early Gardner Fox Years
Satellite League
Detroit
Giffen DeMatteis Justice League International
Dan Jurgens League
Extreme Justice / Task Force
Morrison's JLA followed by Waid
JL Unlimited Animated Series
Meltzer Benes McDuffie League
New 52 Geoff Johns
Rebirth
Snyder Vendetti plus JL Dark / Odyssey
Other
NOTE: Thread originally started December of 2020 by caj
-------------------------
With 158 people having voted,* Satellite League = 47 votes (+1)
* Morrison's JLA followed by Waid = 28 votes
* JL Unlimited Animated Series = 26 votes
* Giffen DeMatteis Justice League International = 17 votes (+1)
* Meltzer Benes McDuffie League = 9 votes
* New 52 Geoff Johns = 7 votes
* Snyder Vendetti plus JL Dark / Odyssey = 6 votes
* "Other" = 6 votes
All other options still have 5 votes or less at last check.
(Extreme Justice / Task Force still doesn't have any votes.)
It's all about JLA Detroit. You have Power, grace, skill and most of all, the suaveness of the courvoisier drinking, ladies man, Dale Gunn.
Although I tried out two issues of Fox & Sekowsky JUSTICE LEAGUE OF AMERICA in the 1960s, I never got the bug for the book until I picked up an issue by Mike Friedrich, Dick Dillin and Joe Giella in 1971 and then I was hooked. To me that was absolutely the most exciting run. And the thing about Friedrich is he plotted it like a Marvel book, so stories had a main plot and a sub plot or two or three and so there were always plot threads continuing on into the next issues. This hadn't happened before and it didn't happen that much after Friedrich left, until the Steve Englehart run.
Yeah, he did... none of it was remotely interesting to me and I don't think I was alone as I recall sales were garbage under him.
Nice to see this thread come back.
Also nice to see that the satellite league needs just one vote to hit 50. Great to see that it gets the love it deserves.
Geoff Johns. I love Cyborg being a founding member. Plus, my favourite supervillain Atomica debuts in that run.
STAS apologist, New 52 apologist, writer of several DC fan projects.
With 166 people having NOW voted,* Satellite League = 49 votes (+2)
* Morrison's JLA followed by Waid = 28 votes
* JL Unlimited Animated Series = 27 votes (+1)
* Giffen DeMatteis Justice League International = 18 votes (+1)
* Meltzer Benes McDuffie League = 11 votes (+2)
* New 52 Geoff Johns = 8 votes (+1)
* Snyder Vendetti plus JL Dark / Odyssey = 6 votes
* "Other" = 6 votes
All other options still have 5 votes or less at last check.
(Extreme Justice / Task Force still doesn't have any votes.)
SO biased against Detroit! We hate how the big 3 carry everything!
Well, no big three in Detroit! No Rings, no Speed, no arrows, just fresh faces with a Fish! and DALE FREAKING GUNN! Ya'll just jealous of Dale's play. He makes Stacy's mom look like an amateur.
The Satellite League needs only one more vote to reach 50.
With 171 people having voted,* Satellite League = 50 votes (+1)
* Morrison's JLA followed by Waid = 29 votes (+1)
* JL Unlimited Animated Series = 27 votes
* Giffen DeMatteis Justice League International = 20 votes (+2)
* Meltzer Benes McDuffie League = 11 votes
* New 52 Geoff Johns = 8 votes
* Snyder Vendetti plus JL Dark / Odyssey = 6 votes
* "Other" = 6 votes
* Early Gardner Fox Years = 6 votes
All other options still have 5 votes or less at last check.
(Extreme Justice / Task Force still doesn't have any votes.)