Originally Posted by
Aahz
One bad scene doesn't really destroy a characters popularity.
Yeah all of the Robins had bad stories, but most of them had also good ones.
Since Flashpoint Damian had Batman and Robin, Robin Son of Batman, several incarnation of Supersons his current Robin and some one shots and elseworlds that were all seen as pretty good.
Dick Grayson (not my taste but alot of people seem to like it), and Nightwing in the past 10 year runs had some bad runs and some pretty good runs.
When I can't really think of any story with him that people really liked in the last ten year, yeah some writers tried to do something but non of it was really a hit. With other Robins it feels like you have at least 50:50 chance to get something good if they have a new run or series announced, with Tim it seems you can expect at best something mediocre.