Originally Posted by
RedBird
I hope not. Jasons actions with Sheila helped to define his character, her integration into DITF wasn't all that great, but firstly that book had bigger absurdities besides Sheila anyways, and secondly there's no reason a modern retelling couldn't help to rework her character a little.
Not that I think she needs much work, she's a character that existed to die within a few issues, she doesn't need to be fleshed out, it's Jasons story that is important here anyway, not Sheila's, she serves as a good reason as to why he would ever approach the warehouse, and helped define his character with the actions he took thereafter.
Besides the only other two alternative takes on why Jason approaches the warehouse in DITF are;
A) That Jason simply makes a rash decision to fight the Joker by himself, which just completely diminishes his positive qualities from the OG story and makes him out as being irrational for almost no reason.
B) Changing the story so that Joker makes Jason think that Catherine is dead, then proceeds to relocate her to Qurac, so that years later, Jason as Robin would follow her there. Which is just point blank, dumb.