Originally Posted by
Drops Of Venus
So I finally saw someone who seemed to genuinely like the America retcon completely and believe it was the best thing for the character... and of course it turned out to be Tumblr's #1 Gillen hater, LMAO. In general, the vast majority of the online fan reaction has been pretty mixed/negative from what I can tell. The last time there was this much bad talk around MAC was in the Rivera days, so if the attempt was to fix that... it kind of backfired.
Yeah, I've been seeing a lot of people comparing this to the Captain Marvel retcon, but I think that one was handled so much better. It didn't feel like it took much away from Carol, and it gave her more layers as a cosmic hero. It opened up the door for broader stories with her. This America retcon, in comparison... it really just feels like taking away her potential. The book even seems to be going as far as to make her less powerful than she was before. I wonder what exactly is in store for her after this if she's not this cosmic powerhouse anymore. That was such a big draw to the character; it's what made her be a part of the Young Avengers/Ultimates and probably what made Kevin Feige want her as a part of Multiverse Of Madness. This grounded approach makes her so much less interesting for these kind of stories now.
I think the lingering questions are probably about the ending of Empyre, since that was the big question mark that he left for Wiccan and Hulkling. I don't expect the MAC retcon to affect Ewing's plans, honestly, unless he was specifically planning to use her in one of those stories in a way that he can't anymore.