Definitely. Perhaps a more apt comparison would be a perfectly made hamburger with fries and complex and challenging gourmet meal. Neither is necessarily better than the other. There's nothing more satisfying than scarfing down a great burger from the drive thru at the end of a hard day, but there's also something to be said for sitting down at a great restaurant and having a skilled chef take you on a wild culinary journey, some of which won't necessarily work for you at first, but is delicious in a completely different way.
In the end, I'm glad Hal Jordan was the beneficiary of such a wide diversity of approaches by so many talented creators.
Where do you get a perfectly made burger at a drive-thru??