Appreciation Thread Indexes
Marvel | Spider-Man | X-Men | NEW!! DC Comics | Batman | Superman | Wonder Woman
As has been posted in the Batgirls and Steph threads, the Baigirls book is official now, so Cass will be co-starring in a comic starting in December.
https://aiptcomics.com/2021/09/15/dc...tgirls-1-2021/
Interestingly, in Infinite Frontier #6, Thomas Wayne (Flashpoint Batman) lists Dick, Jason, Tim, Stephanie, Cass, Duke and Damian as Bruce's children. I am ecstatic that Cassandra has once again been listed as part of the Wayne family but I didn't think Stephanie had been adopted as she still has a mother. Tim I don't know the status of either since the Dark Metal reset, are his parents alive or dead now?
Based on Urban legends 6, Tim was officially adopted.
I'm not sure how much we can read into Cass being adopted based on what Thomas Wayne said, as he basically just listed all of Batman's proteges (minus Babs).
I think that's basically just Williamson apologizing for including only Damian as Batman's son in previous issues, so this time he included everyone that Batman ever mentored.
For example, Babs wasn't mentioned as part of the family here, but she was listed as part of Batman's family in Truth & Justice 6, and was also weirdly included in Damian's list of "adopted sisters" in the Festival of Asian superheroes.
Duke was mentioned as Batman's child by Thomas, but was not a part of the family members listed in Truth & Justice 6, wasn't a part of the family members depicted in Jason and Bruce's family hallucinations, and wasn't included amongst Dick's brothers when he listed them.
So the entire question of who is part of the family is a literal mess right now.
I think that canonically Duke was never adopted and Stephanie was never adopted.
Since Death metal, Dick referred to Bruce as "father", so it's safe to assume he was adopted and referred only to Jason, Tim and Damian as brothers, so we know that all the male Robins are canonically part of the Wayne family right now, and Cass's status seems a bit unclear.
Bendis brought Cluemaster back to life in Young Justice. It was Steph's "arc" in the series learning he was alive and seeking him out to of course "spoil" his criminal enterprise. Likewise, there was a bit of dialogue during their confrontation that Steph and her mom were on speaking terms again and in counseling. Course this was all "pre-Metal".
And behold I shall be a blight upon the land and everything I touch shall wither and die.
Yeah, Steph is in the same situation as Barbara. Parent alive, so isn't part of the Wayne family. But IS part of the Bat family. They'd only become officially part of the Wayne family if they married Tim and Dick respectively.
Cass ought to now be a Wayne (even if she does keep her Cain last name) if her pre-Flashpoint history has been restored. She definitely knows of it at least, and has done since the end of Tynion's Detective Comics run, when she and Steph learned that they used to be Batgirls.
Duke's only adopted in that new Webtoon comic.
Appreciation Thread Indexes
Marvel | Spider-Man | X-Men | NEW!! DC Comics | Batman | Superman | Wonder Woman
Cassandra's Pre-Flashpoint story hasn't been restored.
The idea of Death Metal that characters will remember all their past stories would never work. At the end, it's just an excuse for writers to take parts of the story they want.
They will continue with Cassandra's introduction by Tynion. That's why Cassandra would be a teenager in Batgirls.