Originally Posted by
EmeraldGladiator
Adam that Maddie was kind of blah to me really just a Jean stand in, up until it was revealed she had a hand in Scott losing the X-Men title fight to Storm, but that was a retcon. Maddy didn't really have a voice until the Outback. This is my favorite version of Maddy, she was aiight in X-Man but every other appearance besides Claremont's up until the end of Inferno, I haven't really liked (including the Simonson's butchering of Maddy in X-Factor's Inferno part). She was more layered and nuanced that is the Maddy that made her a favorite character of mine. The pilot of the team, that wanted nothing more than to find her child and get revenge on the Marauders. She was sketchy in X-Man but I was so happy to have Maddy back and not have her just a ghost in Jean's head, I was alright with it.