X-men #17 first look

[nx01a]

Asrar is good, but I liked his work on WAXM a lot better than his current stuff.

I liked Asrar's work on Dynamo 5 a lot better than his later and current stuff.

[Kitty&Piotr<3]

Asrar's recent issues have fallen off from even the X-Men Red days.

[Celestialbodies]

Asrar's recent issues have fallen off from even the X-Men Red days.

I definitely noticed that, I was so excited for him to helm X-men, thinking he's bringing his X-men Red level of work. But from issue to issue sometimes panel to panel his current work looks less refined and a lot more sloppy.


Haven't seen anything close to this yet:

[Rang10]

Asrr is a great artist, but he needs time to draw. Some of his XOS had really rushed pencils

[Soulsword323]

Yu's art was a mixed bag for me. Not only was his posing stiff, but he tended to draw faces in a way that made everyone look dry and elderly. When he pulled out all of the stops, like for the Empyre and X of Swords tie-ins, it looked great. Asrar and Buffagni's fill-in issues got a far better reaction out of me, though.

This. Yu's art doesn't do much for me anymore. He does best when drawing other-worldly characters like Apocalypse and the Brood. X-Men should have some top tier artist working on it, and I wish Marvel would realize that. A shame that RB's on F4.

[Vishop]

He does best when drawing other-worldly characters like Apocalypse and the Brood.

Really? Hickman draws the best Apocalypse smh. He made those designs for Apocalypse that we appreciate till now. In fact I find his Apocalypse much more character rather than Asrar where he was characterized as sad depressed fellow. That's not Apocalypse IMHO.

[Rang10]

Really? Hickman draws the best Apocalypse smh. He made those designs for Apocalypse that we appreciate till now. In fact I find his Apocalypse much more character rather than Asrar where he was characterized as sad depressed fellow. That's not Apocalypse IMHO.

Hickman wrote him as a depressed and sad man

[Rev9]

Yu artwork is thousands times better than Booth. Clearer, better faces, better action

I wanted Yu to go, but Booth is a massive downgrade



Could at least take some generic art that looks good.

I'm willing to give Booth a chance as I don't think I've read an issue of his, but I just wish they gave Carlos Gomez to do a full arc.I loved his art in X-Factor #4

[yogaflame]

I think they meant "Yu" draws the best Poccy.

[MAR420X]

DID anyone forget about the powers of X #6 FOREshadow variant?

I DIDNT

lol guess i was kinda right hahaah great issue!!

[loke13]

Hickman wrote him as a depressed and sad man

Good. He was dealing with one of his greatest lifes failures. He should of been depressed and sad lol

[Bozack]

Yu's work on X-Men lacked the energy we got from Larraz and Silva in HOX and POX. They set the bar. While I'm loving Silva on FF, I wish he had been tapped to be the regular artist on X-Men.

Hickman has to orchestrate a trade or something. Silva belongs on an X-Book.

[Drexelhand]

Really? Hickman draws the best Apocalypse smh. He made those designs for Apocalypse that we appreciate till now. In fact I find his Apocalypse much more character rather than Asrar where he was characterized as sad depressed fellow. That's not Apocalypse IMHO.

Hickman didn't draw that. Has he even done any art for his X-Men stuff beyond maybe storyboards and character designs?