I cannot disagree with your opinion more. We're 8 issues in and Rachel hasn't: a) been mind controlled by a b villain; b) passed out due to the strain of using a mild form of telepathy; c) gotten a "power boost" which was neither power or a boost; or d) entered a romance with someone who would be her godfather;
I can see the criticism that Rachel's voice seems off, but to say that Guggenheim wrote a better Rachel in Gold than what we're seeing now is.... Just.... I can't