Originally Posted by
Matt Parker
I think Long Halloween is a book that is beloved because A) the art is amazing, B) it has great thematic ideas, and C) it encapsulates many corners of the Batman universe and feels definitive in a way (Murder mystery, crime drama, rogues gallery, Wayne family drama, etc.). The story I think falls apart under heavy scrutiny and has plenty of room for improvement, and I don't think the ideas are all that well executed.
There are three big flaws with the book that the movie is addressing for me. One, the logistics of who was responsible for what murders don't add up by the end, and Batman looks dumb for not being able to solve a pretty simple mystery in one year. The movie seems to be laying more definitive clues as to who is Holiday, and it is making the story essentially about Batman's journey into becoming the world greatest detective, so right there I think they turned a huge weakness into a strength.
Two, I think Harvey's turn to the dark side is rushed in the comic. He goes from being the likable DA to stabbing a doctor in the back to escape the hospital in a few pages, and his pre-existing mental health problems are only briefly alluded to in one scene. The film is putting the work in to set up his mental health issues from the beginning, as we see that he was deemed unfit to carry a handgun in his psych eval and is already showing signs of a split personality. Maybe they'll screw the pooch, but I think his transformation might feel much more smooth come part 2.
Finally, I think the film included Joker in a cooler way. In the comic, his escape from Arkham was off panel and didn't seem to be a very big priority for Batman, where here it happens in a super tense sequence and Batman loses his cool once he realizes that the Joker has escaped his cell (seriously, that whole Arkham scene was...chef's kiss). This really ramps up the tension and made the Joker feel like a huge threat.
I really loved the first part (honestly, I think I enjoyed it more than any other comic book flick in at least a few years, and I watched it three times the week it hit on Blu-Ray), so I'm sad it didn't do it for you, Vakanai. At least you always have the comic! And maybe The Batman will be more to your taste.