Ridiculous Comic Nerd Question: All-Star Squadron

[DrNewGod]

In your head canon, how many members does the All-Star Squadron have?

[Riv86672]

Between 30 and 50?

They had members pulled from the ranks of The JSA. The Seven Soldiers of Victory, The Freedom Fighters, and a ton of non team affiliated mystery men.
Not sure it all adds up from pre to post Crisis.

[Lonewolf36]

100 at the most.

[Thirteen]

"All-Star Squadron" = Early concept of Line-wide Crossover event IMO, so EVERYBODY was a member.!

[Digifiend]

Yeah, their membership is everyone from pre-Crisis Earth-2 who was active in World War II, at minimum. As that Who's Who page shows, they also merged in other golden age heroes (such as Plastic Man and Uncle Sam) after the Crisis.

[Riv86672]

Yeah, their membership is everyone from pre-Crisis Earth-2 who was active in World War II, at minimum. As that Who's Who page shows, they also merged in other golden age heroes (such as Plastic Man and Uncle Sam) after the Crisis.

Also after the Crisis, The Squadron of Justice(?). Bulletman and Bulletgirl, Commando Yank, Ibis the Invincible, Minute-Man, Mister Scarlet, Phantom Eagle, Pinky the Whiz Kid, Spy Smasher...

[MajorHoy]

Yeah, their membership is everyone from pre-Crisis Earth-2 who was active in World War II, at minimum. As that Who's Who page shows, they also merged in other golden age heroes (such as Plastic Man and Uncle Sam) after the Crisis.

The additional mergers were a result of all the Earths (Earth-1, Earth-2, Earth-4 (Charlton Comics), Earth-S / Earth-5 (Fawcett comics), Earth-X / Earth-10 (Quality Comics), etc.) pre-CoIE being merged together into a single Earth in post-CoIE continuity.