Results 1 to 11 of 11
  1. #1
    Fantastic Member
    Join Date
    Sep 2020
    Posts
    321

    Post Which version of Marvel Characters is the best version: Comics vs MCU

    Iron Man: MCU
    Captain America: Both
    Thor: Comic
    Black Widow: MCU
    Hawkeye: Comic
    Hulk: Comic
    Nick Fury: MCU
    Falcon: Both
    Winter Soldier: Comic
    Scarlet Witch: MCU
    Vision: Comic
    Agent Coulson: MCU
    Wasp: Comic
    Scott Lang: MCU
    Hank Pym: Comic
    Black Panther: Both
    Doctor Strange: Both
    Star-Lord: MCU
    Rocket Racoon : Both
    Groot: MCU
    Gamora: MCU
    Drax: Comic
    Loki: MCU
    Thanos: MCU
    Malektith: Comic
    Red Skull: Comic
    Nebula: MCU
    Yondu: MCU
    Crossbones: Comic
    Spider-Man: Comic
    Vulture: MCU
    Hela: Both
    Shuri: Comic
    Ghost: Comic
    Executioner: Both
    Killomnger: MCU
    Mysterio: Both
    Agatha Harkness: MCU

    List down your own.

  2. #2
    Amazing Member
    Join Date
    Oct 2020
    Posts
    50

    Default

    Leaving out the ones I haven't seen both versions of:

    Iron Man: MCU
    Captain America: comic (Chris Evans is a perfect Cap tho)
    Thor: Comic
    Black Widow: MCU
    Hawkeye: Comic
    Hulk: Comic
    Nick Fury: MCU
    Falcon: MCU
    Winter Soldier: MCU
    Scarlet Witch: comic
    Vision: Comic
    Agent Coulson: MCU
    Wasp: Comic
    Scott Lang: MCU
    Hank Pym: Comic
    Black Panther: MCU
    Doctor Strange: comic
    Star-Lord: MCU
    Rocket Racoon : MCU
    Groot: MCU
    Gamora: comic
    Drax: Comic
    Loki: comic
    Thanos: comic
    Malektith: Comic
    Red Skull: Comic
    Nebula: MCU
    Yondu: MCU
    Crossbones: Comic
    Spider-Man: Comic
    Shuri: MCU
    Ghost: Comic
    Killomnger: MCU
    Mysterio: MCU
    Agatha Harkness: I feel like this one's hard to judge, I love them both but they're essentially different characters with the same name

    Also I'll add Quicksilver: comic

  3. #3
    Mighty Member
    Join Date
    May 2014
    Posts
    1,449

    Default

    Not the versions I think are best, just the version I prefer.

    Iron Man: MCU
    Captain America: Comic
    Thor: Comic
    Black Widow: MCU
    Hawkeye: Comic
    Hulk: Comic
    Nick Fury: Comic
    Falcon: MCU
    Winter Soldier: Comic
    Scarlet Witch: MCU
    Vision: MCU
    Agent Coulson: MCU
    Wasp: Comic
    Scott Lang: Comic
    Hank Pym: Comic
    Black Panther: Comic
    Doctor Strange: Comic
    Star-Lord: Comic until the Comic started reflecting the MCU then MCU because I'd rather just have MCU Starlord instead of the comic version of MCU Starlord.
    Rocket Racoon : Comic
    Groot: MCU
    Gamora: MCU
    Drax: MCU
    Loki: Comic
    Thanos: Comic
    Malektith: Comic
    Red Skull: Comic
    Nebula: MCU
    Yondu: Comic
    Crossbones: Comic
    Spider-Man: Comic
    Vulture: MCU
    Hela: Comic
    Shuri: Comic
    Ghost: Comic
    Executioner: Ehh
    Killomnger: Comic
    Mysterio: Comic
    Agatha Harkness: Comic
    Quicksilver: Comic

  4. #4
    Astonishing Member
    Join Date
    Apr 2014
    Posts
    3,971

    Default

    Iron Man: MCU
    Captain America: Comic
    Thor: Comic
    Black Widow: Comic
    Hawkeye: Comic
    Hulk: Comic
    Nick Fury: MCU
    Falcon: MCU
    Winter Soldier: Comic
    Scarlet Witch: MCU
    Vision: Comic
    Agent Coulson: MCU
    Wasp: Comic
    Scott Lang: MCU
    Hank Pym: Comic
    Black Panther: Both
    Doctor Strange: Both
    Star-Lord: MCU
    Rocket Racoon : Both
    Groot: MCU
    Gamora: MCU
    Drax: Comic
    Loki: MCU
    Thanos: Comic
    Malektith: Comic
    Red Skull: Comic
    Nebula: MCU
    Yondu: MCU
    Crossbones: Comic
    Spider-Man: Comic
    Vulture: MCU
    Hela: Both
    Shuri: Comic
    Ghost: Comic
    Executioner: Both
    Killomnger: MCU
    Mysterio: Both
    Agatha Harkness: Comic

  5. #5
    Wanda & Ribrianne~4~Life! CJStriker's Avatar
    Join Date
    Apr 2014
    Location
    Connecticut
    Posts
    11,588

    Smile

    Iron Man: Both
    Captain America: Both
    Thor: Both
    Black Widow: Both
    Hawkeye: Comic
    Hulk: Both
    Nick Fury: Both
    Falcon: Both
    Winter Soldier: Both
    Scarlet Witch: Both
    Vision: Both
    Agent Coulson: MCU
    Wasp: Comic
    Scott Lang: Both
    Hank Pym: Both
    Black Panther: Both
    Doctor Strange: Both
    Star-Lord: MCU
    Rocket Racoon : Both
    Groot: Both
    Gamora: Comic
    Drax: Both
    Loki: Both
    Thanos: Both
    Malektith: Comic
    Red Skull: Both
    Nebula: Both
    Yondu: Both
    Crossbones: Comic
    Spider-Man: Both
    Vulture: Both
    Hela: Both
    Shuri: Both
    Ghost: MCU
    Executioner: Both
    Killomnger: MCU
    Mysterio: Both
    Agatha Harkness: Both
    Quicksilver: Both
    "By Earth and Sky, By Craft and Hex -- By The Past and The Future I Call HOPE Forth From The DARKNESS!
    I Speak The Words We Made Into MAGIC!
    Let THEIR Power Augment Our OWN! To Strike ONE BLOW From Our HEARTS and SOULS From ALL THAT WE ARE!
    Let The CALL Go Forth --
    AVENGERS! ASSEMBLE!"


    Scarlet Witch/Wanda Maximoff ~~ From Avengers #689!

    Come Join and Learn about Wanda Maximoff at: The Scarlet Witch Appreciation Thread 2021!

  6. #6
    Mighty Member
    Join Date
    May 2014
    Posts
    1,761

    Default

    In almost every case, I go with the comic version over the MCU version --- just for all of the history. The only example that comes to mind where the MCU version MAY be slightly better is Scott Lang.

  7. #7

    Default

    Iron Man: Comic
    Captain America: Both
    Thor: Comic
    Black Widow: Comic
    Hawkeye: Comic
    Hulk: Comic
    Nick Fury: MCU
    Falcon: Both
    Winter Soldier: Comic
    Scarlet Witch: Comic
    Vision: MCU
    Agent Coulson: MCU
    Wasp: Comic
    Scott Lang: MCU
    Hank Pym: Comic
    Black Panther: Both
    Doctor Strange: Both
    Star-Lord: Comic
    Rocket Racoon : Both
    Groot: Both
    Gamora: Comic
    Drax: Comic
    Loki: Both
    Thanos: Both
    Malekith: Comic
    Red Skull: Comic
    Nebula: Both
    Yondu: Comic
    Crossbones: Comic
    Spider-Man: Comic
    Vulture: MCU
    Hela: Both
    Shuri: Comic
    Ghost: Comic
    Executioner: Both
    Killomnger: MCU
    Mysterio: Both
    Agatha Harkness: Comic
    Quicksilver: Comic
    Last edited by GenericUsername; 04-11-2021 at 07:44 PM.
    Love is for souls, not bodies.

  8. #8
    Mighty Member useridgoeshere's Avatar
    Join Date
    Apr 2014
    Posts
    1,266

    Default

    Just doing leads ...

    Spider-Man: Comic
    Iron Man: MCU
    Captain America: MCU
    Thor: MCU
    Black Widow: Comic
    Hawkeye: Comic
    Hulk: Comic
    Nick Fury: MCU
    Wanda: MCU
    Vision: Comic
    Falcon: Comic
    Winter Soldier: Comic
    Ant-Man: MCU
    Wasp: Comic
    Black Panther: Comic
    Doctor Strange: Comic
    Captain Marvel: MCU
    Star-Lord: MCU
    Rocket Racoon: MCU
    Groot: MCU
    Gamora: MCU
    Drax: Comic

    Quote Originally Posted by kcekada View Post
    In almost every case, I go with the comic version over the MCU version --- just for all of the history. The only example that comes to mind where the MCU version MAY be slightly better is Scott Lang.
    In some cases, for me the history works against the comics version. Captain Marvel, Wanda and Captain America are examples.
    Last edited by useridgoeshere; 04-11-2021 at 07:57 PM.

  9. #9

    Default

    Quote Originally Posted by useridgoeshere View Post
    Just doing leads ...

    Spider-Man: Comic
    Iron Man: MCU
    Captain America: MCU
    Thor: MCU
    Black Widow: Comic
    Hawkeye: Comic
    Hulk: Comic
    Nick Fury: MCU
    Wanda: MCU
    Vision: Comic
    Falcon: Comic
    Winter Soldier: Comic
    Ant-Man: MCU
    Wasp: Comic
    Black Panther: Comic
    Doctor Strange: Comic
    Captain Marvel: MCU
    Star-Lord: MCU
    Rocket Racoon: MCU
    Groot: MCU
    Gamora: MCU
    Drax: Comic


    In some cases, for me the history works against the comics version. Captain Marvel, Wanda and Captain America are examples.
    I don't really agree with this. Sure for something like AD/HoM, they did a worse job with her. But Wanda has a lot more time as a hero in comics and lead teams. Went on a lot more adventures as an Avenger.
    Love is for souls, not bodies.

  10. #10
    Mighty Member useridgoeshere's Avatar
    Join Date
    Apr 2014
    Posts
    1,266

    Default

    Quote Originally Posted by GenericUsername View Post
    I don't really agree with this. Sure for something like AD/HoM, they did a worse job with her. But Wanda has a lot more time as a hero in comics and lead teams. Went on a lot more adventures as an Avenger.
    Well, of course, you don't agree. I wouldn't expect you to. At this point, I can't foresee a scenario where I'd even like comics Wanda, while I love MCU Wanda after WandaVision.

    I've seen how this goes, so let me say, I cannot be badgered into changing my mind.

  11. #11

    Default

    Quote Originally Posted by useridgoeshere View Post
    Well, of course, you don't agree. I wouldn't expect you to. At this point, I can't foresee a scenario where I'd even like comics Wanda, while I love MCU Wanda after WandaVision.

    I've seen how this goes, so let me say, I cannot be badgered into changing my mind.
    Lol, no worries, not gonna badger you. Just voicing my own displeasure of how she's been depicted so far. I do hope that improves in Strange 2, though.
    Love is for souls, not bodies.

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •