Does Scarlet Witch get along well with the X-Men?

[Lucyinthesky]

Wanda bounced back better than most & people are just bitter about it, it's not her fault.

I think she has not bounced back thematically speaking she´s stuck on the HoM storyline.

I Think Rogue and Polaris dont hate her.

But the trial needs to also be the det-retcon-decon.

So make the twins Mags again.

I second this

Rogue, Beast, Wolverine, Nightcrawler,Lorna,Multiple Man,Rictor and Magneto are friendly to her, the rest of the X-men don´t hate her but are cold to her, lest just address this inside story to let everyone go on with their respective stories.

[PhoenixThanos]

I Think Rogue and Polaris dont hate her.

But the trial needs to also be the det-retcon-decon.

So make the twins Mags again.

FB_IMG_1619117986687.jpg
Yes get rid of that stupid retcon

[Covetous_One]

It's cold on most fronts rouge is the only one I can think of who remotely cares for her but the others don't. But I will say this....
I do not know how the mutants as a whole can even forgive her, undoubtedly there will be some mutants that will be greatfull for being normal, but that is for those whose mutation is not related to their survival but hated being mutants. But most mutants their mutations are essential to surviving. I heard somewhere that for every storm or magneto we have a thousand blobs. What wanda did weather influenced or not was and is very bad. The fact that she was revealed not to be a mutant later on just added salt to the wounds. I do not agree with the crucible buy I understand y it is a thing. It is literally a way of reclaiming back the trauma of M day. Many wanda fans care only about the fact that wanda is being blamed for what she did on M day, saying mutants and x fans should forget about it that it is in the past and that doom or whatever was responsible not her. But will turn on their heads and use M day as feats in battle threads.
I support wanda going through her journey she has to find peace with what she did. But that shouldn't be at the expense of her victims who suffered under her actions from that day. In way of x a mutant who has gravity powers taken from her during M day underwent the crucible to gain back her power because she was in great pain without it. Many mutants are in her shoes many are tormented and many even died from losing their power. All this along with the hardship of just being a mutant is more than most can bear. Unfortunately Fabian Cortez in the latest sword issue was right about one thing, mutants have to stop considering the feelings of their oppressors because weather they like it or not this is a game of survival literally and humans are not gonna play nice, I mean what did they do when krakoa was announced built a giant space station to kill the mutant nation in it's infancy.

Technically that space station was already built during Marvel’s Illuminate arc, Orchis just repurposed it for their plans. Wanda was insane at the time and still has mental health issues. If you want to put someone on trial due to an episode of insanity okay, but they will get called out on it.

[PhoenixThanos]

I think she has not bounced back thematically speaking she´s stuck on the HoM storyline.



I second this

Rogue, Beast, Wolverine, Nightcrawler and Magneto are friendly to her, the rest of the X-men don´t hate her but are cold to her, lest just address this inside story to let everyone go on with their respective stories.

There is absolutely no way either Beast or Wolverine are friendly to her, they would punish Wanda in an heart beat

[Lucyinthesky]

Beast found her on Wundagore when he was looking for a cure to decimation and didn´t told anyone where was she hidding, Wolverine attacked her on Children´s Crusade but told Rogue to be more friendly on Uncanny Avengers(it´s the problem with multiple writers) so I count them as friendly to her.

[Paragon]

Rogue, Beast, Wolverine, Nightcrawler,Lorna,Multiple Man,Rictor and Magneto are friendly to her, the rest of the X-men don´t hate her but are cold to her, lest just address this inside story to let everyone go on with their respective stories.

I am surprised I can't remember Jamie and Wanda appearing in a comic together since House of M. Have I forgotten some random scene in X-Factor, or was this somewhere else?

[Lucyinthesky]

It was on Children´s Crusade Jamie made X-factors mission to discover what happened during decimation so Children´s Crusade was a kind of close up for that story. He wasn´t exactly friendly but he was open to let her try to bring rictor´s powers back.

[CJStriker]

There is absolutely no way either Beast or Wolverine are friendly to her, they would punish Wanda in an heart beat

That Last Major Interaction between Wanda and Logan was back in Uncanny Avengers Vol. 1, Issue #24 and by the dialogue of that Issue they where on Friendly Terms.

[raidensix]

That Last Major Interaction between Wanda and Logan was back in Uncanny Avengers Vol. 1, Issue #24 and by the dialogue of that Issue they where on Friendly Terms.

The writers tried to shift the blame to Doctor Doom and the "Life Force". But it would still be Wanda's decision to seek Victor's help in the first place.

[ExodusCloak]

This is how the X-men feel but keep in mind their tolerance and lack of pitchforks doesn't represent the wider mutant community who hate her guts. She was the boogeyman in Bishops future. The X-Men tolerate her but they don't want to be in the same room as her as to not evoke very negative feelings.

[PhoenixThanos]

Beast found her on Wundagore when he was looking for a cure to decimation and didn´t told anyone where was she hidding, Wolverine attacked her on Children´s Crusade but told Rogue to be more friendly on Uncanny Avengers(it´s the problem with multiple writers) so I count them as friendly to her.

I think how Beast is currently being portrayed in the X books (especially his treatment of Colossus) Wanda would be wise to stay away from him, it's probably why she hasn't responded to his email about testing out an Krakoan Gateway in Strange Academy.
Uncanny Avengers Vol 1 #24 was a long time ago, who honestly knows how Logan (Wolverine) will react towards Wanda

[Lucyinthesky]

I think how Beast is currently being portrayed in the X books (especially his treatment of Colossus) Wanda would be wise to stay away from him, it's probably why she hasn't responded to his email about testing out an Krakoan Gateway in Strange Academy.
Uncanny Avengers Vol 1 #24 was a long time ago, who honestly knows how Logan (Wolverine) will react towards Wanda

Wanda and Hank were friends during his Avengers time and he protected her safety despite being desperate to find a way out of decimation but I get what you are saying, right now he´s being written in such a way that he´s unrecognizable as a character as for Logan it depends on the writer really but I don´t really think he holds strong angry feelings over her but if he´s told he has to stop her, he probably will, no questions asked, then agai, he would also do this to bassically anyone else if he believes he has to so I would not see this as a particular bias towards her.

I posted those images because I think it´s unfair to keep this perception like the X-men are just a group who are unfair or unreasonable to judge Wanda, I think they have been extremely civil to her considering what happened and some of them have tried to be understanding of her situation, because it was really a time where she lost control of herself in the middle of a fight but this doesn´t mean that what she did was not wrong, it was wrong and the mutants or X-men who keep a grudge on Wanda are also in their right to keep it, they should not be seen as villains just because they see decimation that way.

I like to think of this as that old grudge between Carol and Rogue, both are heroines and respect each other as that but they definitely don´t like each other and both have a good reason for this. I think if the X or A writers are going to approach the decimation with Wanda and the X-men again they should take this approach to really tell a well balanced story because so far we have got the A-writers saying "the X-men are just unfair and resentful" and "X-writers going; Wanda is mutantkind boogeyman" I think it should be better to find a balance between those two discourses.

[CJStriker]

I think how Beast is currently being portrayed in the X books (especially his treatment of Colossus) Wanda would be wise to stay away from him, it's probably why she hasn't responded to his email about testing out an Krakoan Gateway in Strange Academy.
Uncanny Avengers Vol 1 #24 was a long time ago, who honestly knows how Logan (Wolverine) will react towards Wanda

Indeed it was a good time ago, makes me feel old LOL, but indeed it is the last major interation I can remember and I have read a good amount of Wolverine stories since then and don't recall a more recent one, so I go with that as the most recent of significances until I get any stories after that I missed or forgot in the main canon books.

Their was also Old Man Logan interation with Wanda a few years back to, but that was just 1 panel about him going back to his alternate future time to take on the Hulk Gang as I remember, so I count that as alternative Wolverine their.

[Vordan]

Rogue forgave after literally stabbing and attempting to murder her. Whats a little death between friends?



Actually, I wonder if the X-Men might view her differently if she voluntarily went through the Crucible... well, whenever her non-mutant status gets rectonned that is.

Pretty sure that’s what all this is leading up to. They brutally murder Wanda so her “debt” is paid and then she gets a clean slate like all the other genociders they have on the Quiet Council.

[Rang10]

I think how Beast is currently being portrayed in the X books (especially his treatment of Colossus) Wanda would be wise to stay away from him, it's probably why she hasn't responded to his email about testing out an Krakoan Gateway in Strange Academy.
Uncanny Avengers Vol 1 #24 was a long time ago, who honestly knows how Logan (Wolverine) will react towards Wanda

It was totally a trap, I wouldn't trust Beast