No, I count Avengers by Byrne as Vol 3. That’s why I have it primarily as “by Thomas”, since they can’t really continue the numbering without massive double dipping. I just tossed the 4 on there to ensure it gets tallied with any other permutations that others might vote for.
I brew the beer you drink. What's your super power?
These were both on my list. I’d be very happy if they get made.
The Thanos one, I had these:
Captain Marvel (1999) #11,#17-18, Infinity Abyss (2002) #1-6, Marvel Universe: The End (2003) #1-6, Thanos (2003) #1-6, material from Marvel Universe: Millennial Visions #1 ("Infinity Watch: Wish Upon a Star"). Even though they aren’t Starlin, I think to pad it out I’d put Thanos 7-12 in as well.
Last edited by BurgerKing; 05-14-2021 at 03:27 AM.
This would be awesome. I think it might be 2 omnis:
Warlock & the Infinity Watch Omnibus Volume 1
Warlock & the Infinity Watch 1-22, Silver Surfer/Warlock: Resurrection 1-4
Warlock & the Infinity Watch Omnibus Volume 2
Thor 468-471, Silver Surfer (1987) 86-88, Warlock Chronicles (1993) 6-8 and Warlock and the Infinity Watch (1992-1995) 23-42
I’d also like a Galactus Omnibus
Fantastic four (1961) #48-50 (Coming of Galactus), #72, #74-77 (when calls galactus), #120-123, #208-214 (in search for galactus), #242-244, #257-262 (trial of galactus), Thor (1966) #160-162, #168-169 (Origin of Galactus), #225-228, Super Villains Classic One-shot (1983), silver surfer (1968) #1, #4, Silver surfer (1987) #1-10, #17-18, Galactus the Devourer (1999) #1-6, Parable, Requiem, Last Galactus Story
I love me some Moon Knight and did not put any additional MK Omnis on my list cause I feel when the show is ready to debut on Disney+ they are likely to give us a new one. I'd like a vol.1 of the Marc Spector late 80s/early 90s series that went 60 issues. I think making that series two volumes with tie-in appearances would work well.
Likewise I didn't include Spectacular Spider-man due to MMW soliciting up thru a vol.4, I feel a Spec Omni is more a sure thing. It may be 2 years but it feels as certain as certain gets with this hobby.
"Freedom is the right of all sentient beings" - Optimus Prime
SSM seems so ripe for an omnibus in so many ways - V1 just to start it, a companion to the Stern omni (presumably volume 2), DeMatteis's run, Peter David's run, Conway's run (btw, why hasn't there been a Tombstone v2 tpb to finish that??), the Alien Costume Saga - pick a spot! After the inevitable ASM v6, they're going to have to start branching out into other directions . . .
Blue text denotes sarcasm
I'm not even picky - epic collections, omnis, a series of creator-fronted complete collections (e.g. SSM by Peter David v1 and v2), whatever - just give me the opportunity to have some nice collections of SSM (and Web, and the post-Larsen adjectiveless up to the Clone Saga . . .).
Blue text denotes sarcasm
From Tigereyes:
Omar is going to reveal the Top 50. It will be on Sunday on his channel.
Happy to see Stern's Avengers in the top 5. That is my number 1 and I NEED it soon! Quickly followed by a volume 2.
My list for this year was :
1.Spectacular Spider-Man by J.M.DeMatteis.
2.Captain America by Mark Gruenwald.
3-Captain America by J.M.DeMatteis.
4-Incredible Hulk by Bill Mantlo.
5-Wolverine by Larry Hama.
6.Avengers by Roger Stern.
7.Ghost Rider by Howard Mackie.
8-Spider-Man 2099 Vol.1.
9-Amazing Spider-Man by Tom de Falco.
10-Amazing Spider-Man by David Michelinie and Mark Bagley.
The Complete LIST:
1 Uncanny X-Men Vol 5
2 Thor Aaron
3 Daredevil Nocenti
4 Spectacular Spider-Man Dematties
5 Avengers Stern 1
6 Amazing Spider-Man Michelinie Bagley
7 Alpha Flight Vol 2
8 Superior Spider-man
9 Black Panther Priest Vol 1
10 Silver Surfer Englehart
11 Hulk SA 2
12 Captain America Gruenwald Vol 1
13 Rom (Romnibus)
14 House of M
15 X-Men Carey Vol 1
16 Spectacular Spider-Man Vol 1
17 Amazing Spider-Man Vol 6
18 Avengers Vol 5
19 X-Men Inferno Aftermath
20 Moon Knight Vol 2
21 Ghost Rider Ketch Vol 1
22 Fantastic Four Vol 5
23 Star Wars Gillen/Pak
24 Wolverine vol 3
25 Iron Man Micheline Vol 2
26 Amazing Spider-Man Defalco Vol 1
27 Spider-Man 2099
28 Incredible Hulk Mantlo
29 Generation X Vol 1
30 Spider-Man Alien Costume 2
31 Doctor Strange SA 2 (NOTE: Dropped off considerably once announced, was at one point in the Top 3)
32 Thunderbolts Vol 3 (through New Thunderbolts)
33 X-Men Lost Years MMW 7-8, Epic 4 and Hidden Years
**Most people voted for it to include Hidden Years, some voted as two separate books
34 (TIE) Micronauts
34 (TIE) New Avengers 2 Road to Secret Invasion
35 X-Factor Investigations David
36 Daredevil Vol 2
37 Ultimate Spider-Man Vol 2
38 Miracleman
39 Iron Man Fraction
40 Captain Britain & MI13
41 Silver Surfer Starlin
42 X-Force Kyle Yost
43 Punisher Rucka
44 Spider-Woman 1970's
45 Quasar Gruenwald
46 Iron Man SA 3
47 Marvel Team Up Vol 1
48 Messiah Complex Saga
49 X-Treme X-Men
50 Sub-Mariner Vol 1