This is my Spider-Man ranking:
1: Peter ( 616).
2:,Peter ( AU’s)
3: Miguel.
4: Miles ( AU’s
5: Otto
6: Miles (616).
7: Ben.
I would even rank some of the ladies like Annie, Julia and Gwen ahead of Ben ( just ahead of Cindy). To me Ben is nothing more then a “Substitute Teacher” filling in for Peter just like these new writers are subs waiting for Zdarsky, Cates or some other prominent writer to take over.
Here's the thing - that's my opinion. Period.
And this here is yours. Period.
End of.
A trend I see way too often on these Boards is people failing to accept a different opinion to theirs.
Now that's hilarious.
Guess we've both made each others day with hilarious posts.
And IF you can't connect the dots to why I rank Peter there based on what came before...not sure what to tell you friend.
Last edited by Mr. White; 06-25-2021 at 07:05 AM.
the best Spider-Man is the one I like cant tell me otherwise
"He's pure power and doesn't even know it. He's the best of us."-Matt Murdock
"I need a reason to take the mask off."-Peter Parker
"My heart half-breaks at how easy it is to lie to him. It breaks all the way when he believes me without question." Felicia Hardy
I mean sure but at that point you aren't discussing it.
You can like hot dogs with grape jelly soaked in Coke Zero.And you have the right to like and no one can tell you otherwise.
Our discussion is who is the better Spider-man subjectively.As in who is better in canon in respect to stories, characterization , supporting cast, villains, etc.
Also I made this thread because people were claiming that Miles and Ock win in polls.Clearly this is not the case.
Miles doesn't even have 1 vote.
Last edited by Spiderfan001; 06-25-2021 at 07:19 AM.
Last edited by Somecrazyaussie; 06-25-2021 at 07:28 AM.
Heh heh. Alright mates.
Lemme indulge you a little bit more.
If you would be so kind to elaborate on how the dots "don't make much sense"... to you..
@SF001 - based on your response to @Jman 27 - the objective of your poll appears to be geared at "proving" (if that is the right word) that Peter is better than Miles/ Ock. You do know that whatever majority here think is not the law right? Like it's just popular opinion. Even if everyone was to vote for Spider-Ham. Point is, it all boils down to who each an everyone likes.
Also asking "who is better in canon in respect to stories, characterization , supporting cast, villains, etc." - the mere fact one character (1) is the "main" one and (2) the one which has existed the longest - probability is that character would edge out the others as there has been more time invested in it/him.
Well why don't you re-read your posts and make sense of them and connect the dots for us.It will save for more time.
Again because people said that Miles and Ock won in popularity polls.That is an popularity poll that proves otherwise.
Again I said even when you compare the first 10 years for both characters Peter has superior stories, characterization , supporting cast, villains, etc. in comparison to Miles.
Hmm.
Seems there was a break in communication somewhere. Going to try some realignment.
> Our discussion started with Metro's response to my post (which you co-signed) where he says: "The idea Peter ever comes after Miles is just hilarious, like at least with Ben and Kaine they actually have personalities and have things differently than Peter. Miles? No real characterization whatsoever, and all he has ever done is rehash what Peter has already done, so it's near impossible for me to see this as anything other than hilarious, because you can't say Peter is boring and then go on and prop up a character who just does what Peter does."
> What I get from this is you both are unable to see why I rank Peter below Miles (and the 3 others I mentioned).
> Now my post was pretty clear as it gave reasons why I prefer the others to Peter which, if you recall (you may have to re-read), I chalk up to Marvel's general attitude towards him.
> You both say "it doesn't make sense".
So I guess the question I should have asked is - What doesn't make sense?(/ What don't you understand from the original post?).
(NB: it's an opinion not an arguement . Not speaking for the masses).