X-men #1 reviews (spoilers)

[Glio]

So, he has introduced three new villains in a single issue, interesting.

The X-Men were in dire need of new new villains and that the classics have joined Krakoa is the perfect excuse.

[JB]

Any real life New Yorkers know what’s currently at 86th street and Central Park?

The 86th Street traverse runs along the Jackie Kennedy reservoir, big tourist spot. I'm not sure if the Treehouse is located near W 86th or E 86th but I think they mentioned the west side. East side is the Met... oooO maybe they'll crash a Met Gala.

[gonnagiveittoya]

It a pity but this isn’t for me. Duggan’s writing is so bland. The narration boxes are pain to get through. And laura is a prime example why you don’t let fans pick characters for writers to write. If he want to write logan let him use logan don’t let him turn laura in a b-tec logan smh.

...Laura wasn't the character people voted on. Polaris was.

[dirtynun]

what exactly felt "fresh" about it in your eyes? Just curious.

I think superheroics you know villan of the day, who punches harder, fighting for constant survival kind of fresh. Sadly there are others that see mutantkind thriving and not dying as "problematic"

[Filthy Mutie]

The Elon Musk villain is good, because Elon Musk is trash and the character's heel-turn is believable. The giant robot seemed totally unnecessary (even for a superhero comic), but I guess it was different? Sunfire seemed pretty tacked-on.

Like Duggan, love Larraz - I will stick around and see where it goes!

[Captain Nash]

This was a great issue. All that's missing is Gambit.

[Alex.]

This was a great issue. New villains, new interesting designs, humans not knowing humans could be brought back.

[loke13]

This was a great issue. New villains, new interesting designs, humans not knowing humans could be brought back.

Which is kind of hilarious because I'm not really sure how Krakoa was supposed to keep the fact that mutants are effectively immortal a secret for long lol or high they were going to explain the mutant population going from a couple thousand to Millions in like just one year. Somebody was gonna put 2 and 2 together.

[Tre Styles]

I got good vibes from this issue. Of course excited to see my guy Synch being used in a great manner, showing initiative and all that jazz. I like the concept of the X-Men being accepted back and welcomed back, but I have a feeling that will turn. A solid first issue, not too deep, but just enough to whet the appetite!

[rhaenylis]

...Laura wasn't the character people voted on. Polaris was.

And his Polaris is great

[loke13]

I got good vibes from this issue. Of course excited to see my guy Synch being used in a great manner, showing initiative and all that jazz. I like the concept of the X-Men being accepted back and welcomed back, but I have a feeling that will turn. A solid first issue, not too deep, but just enough to whet the appetite!

I imagine that'll probably come along when Inferno is wrapped up. Whatever goes down in that title has me think the general publics opinion of Krakao is gonna skew more towards the negative.

[RamaBird]

I'd say when it comes to him getting their voices it was:

Great:
Polaris and Synch

Good:
Rogue (maybe she's this high cause her run on Excalibur got me to drop my standards lol).
Jean

Bland:
Cyclops

Needs Lots of Improvement:
Wolverine
Sunfire

[Winter_fury]

...Laura wasn't the character people voted on. Polaris was.

My mistake I thought the whole team was chosen by fans??. Regardless he is writing her out of character.

[Havok83]

My mistake I thought the whole team was chosen by fans??. Regardless he is writing her out of character.

No, just Lorna. Duggan chose the rest

[Winter_fury]

No, just Lorna. Duggan chose the rest

Thanks i edit my original post.