Ranking X-books-01.jpg
Ranking your favourite X-books based on the chart.
Ranking X-books-01.jpg
Ranking your favourite X-books based on the chart.
Ranking them as of up to where they are now/ended:
1. Hellions
2. Cable
3. X-Factor
4. S.W.O.R.D.
5. X-Men (Hickman)
6. Way of X
7. X-Men (Duggan)
8. Marauders (dropping further down as time passes)
9. X-Force (picking back up, but this dropped a lot after the first - amazing - arc)
10. New Mutants (picked up significantly since Ayala took over)
11. Wolverine
12. X-Corp
13. Excalibur
14. Children of the Atom
15. Fallen Angels
Last edited by AlligatorSky; 08-22-2021 at 02:33 PM.
Not read everything, but here's mine for what i have read
1. X-men (Hickman)
2. Way of X
3. New Mutants (Ayla)
3.5. SWORD (forgot about this, had to edit it in)
4. X-force
5. New Mutants (Hickman)
6. X-men (Duggan, only read 1 issue so far however).
7. Excalibur
8. Wolverine
9. New Mutants (Brisson)
10. X-Corp
Superior: SWORD, Hellions
Amazing: New Mutants (Ayala), X-Men (Duggan)
Great: X-Factor, Way of X
Okay: Marauders, Cable, X-Men (Hickman: some issues were higher ranked)
Meh: COTA, Excalibur (used to be trash), Wolverine (mostly my personal preference the book itself is fine), X-Force (used to be higher might lower soon)
Trash: Fallen Angels, X-Corp, New Mutants (Brisson)
Last edited by Kingdom X; 08-23-2021 at 08:27 AM.
X-Men by Hickman is superior to everything else IMO.
following that, I like Hellions and X-force.
New mutants, Children of the Atom, Marauders and Wolverine are below them. I like them and read them, but they never really WOW me.
The absolute worst reads for me are Excalibur and X-Factor. Both almost unreadable
Superior: SWORD, X-Men (Hickman)
Amazing: X-Men (Duggan), Hellions, New Mutants (Hickman), Giant Size One Shots
Great: X-Factor, Marauders
Okay: Way of X, Cable, New Mutants (Ayala), X-Force (used to be higher), X-Corp
Meh: Wolverine
Trash: Children of the Atom, Excalibur, New Mutants (Brisson), Fallen Angels
Superior: Hellions, X-Men
Amazing: SWORD
Great: X-Factor
Okay: Wolverine, Marauders
Meh: X-Force, New Mutants, X-Corp, Cable
Trash: COTA, Fallen Angels, Excalibur
Superior: Hellions, SWORD
Okay: Wolverine, Duggan X-Men, X-Factor
Meh: HiX-Men, Marauders, X-Force, New Mutants, Cable
Trash: COTA, Fallen Angels, X-Corp, Excalibur
1. Hellions
2. S.W.O.R.D.
3. X-Men (Hickman)
4. X-Factor
5. Cable
6. Way of X
7. X-Men (Duggan)
8. Marauders
9. Empyre X-Men
10. Giant Size X-Men
11. New Mutants
12. X-Force
13. Wolverine
14. Excalibur
15. X-Corp
16. Fallen Angels
17. X-Men + Fantastic 4
18. Children of the Atom
Last edited by Milici; 08-23-2021 at 06:24 AM.
Top tier:
1) X-Men (Hickman)
2) X-Factor (Thinkfast material)
3) Marauders (If only Iceman was more proeminent in the book)
4) Hellions (the good surprise)
5) X-Men (Duggan)
6) Way of X
7) Cable
8) SWORD
Ok to meh tier:
9) New Mutants (No more Glob)
10) Wolverine
11) X-Force (Plant vs Zombie)
12) X-Corp
13) Excalibur aka Betsylibur
14) Children of the atom
15) Fallen Angels
(its amazing to see how many titles we had, considering the famine we have been through for years)
Enjoy nearly all the time
1) Hellions
2) SWORD
3) X-Factor
4) Hickman New Mutants
5) Hickman X-Men
6) Ayala New Mutants
More Good than Bad
7) Marauders (Though it's gone downhill post of X of Swords)
8) Excalibur (much improved post X of Swords)
9) Cable
Meh
10)Children of the Atom - Well written but don't understand why this book of new characters exists when we have loads of X-kids getting ignored in other books.
11) Way of X - Would enjoy this a lot more if Nightcrawler was vaguely in character
12) X-Corp
Why did I ever read this?
13) Fallen Angels
14) Brisson New Mutants
Not read
Wolverine
X-Force
Too Early To Say
Duggan X-Men
I feel like the only defender of Brisson's New Mutants, especially those last few issues.
Great
Hellions - still well written. fun book.
SWORD - so far so good. good mix of characters and concepts so far.
Good
X-Men (Hickman) - feels like it never really got started. still was mostly good minus Hordeculture.
Way of X - not bad so far
New Mutants (Hickman) - really should have stayed longer. only writer that seems can use Cannonball and Sunspot....
Okay
X-Force - it started off all right but has kinda went nowhere since. probably derailed by crossovers but this plant monster stuff sucks. let's see Mikhail.
Meh
X-Factor - it wasn't great but better than titles that outlived it.feels like it was trying too hard to do something but I don't even know what.
X-Men (Duggan) - even Larraz's amazing art can't say this. Duggan should go.
Wolverine - I've barely looked at this though I'm just not interested in a Wolverine solo
Cable - not into solo books or Kid Cable
New Mutants -neither writer since Hickman left has done anything worth it
Children of the Atom - just whatever. it feels like a book there to appeal to twitter. non interested kids doing the fake mutant thing is just .... meh.
Trash aka Howard and Duggan!
Excalibur - I'm not sure how this is going this long. The roster made no sense and most of it is still being wasted.
Marauders - might as well rename this Kate and Emma. nobody else does anything. the drunken partying was dumb. the Hellfire Brats/Vivendi are terrible characters. nothing is happening.
X-Corp -sorry this book is just bad. the art is atrocious and the story is super bland. it doesn't work at all.
Fallen Angels. thankfully this wasn't long. art and story sucked)