My opinion is that any change, changes (or should) change the character. It might not be obvious or significant enough for us to see it in every panel, but it is there.
For instance, Matt Murdock is Catholic. His religion isn't something that always appear in his stories, but it's part of his background. In other words, it's in the the toolbox for the writer when they want to use it.
You change the race or the sex, you change the toolbox.
Maybe my perspective is due to the fact that I don't really know what race I belong to. I pass as white in most parts of the world but not where I live. And I'm multi-ethnic enough not to consider myself Caucasian either. But I think that if I did have a stronger racial identity, I'd feel very differently about many things. And maybe people around me - my "readers" - wouldn't be able to tell. But if something happened in my life - if my "writer" decided for that - I could react differently.
Same is true for my gender. I’m a cis-woman but I’m not super feminine. In many ways, my brain works more like a male brain does (based on what science has shown in brain scans, guys, don’t get political about it, please). But I’m not a man and I’d be significantly different if I was.
So, for me, any of those changes always changes the character. But that's really just my opinion.
Something that I considered after I posted.
Consider the AU versions of the characters... AoA Scott, for instance: he grew up in an entirely different background, he played the role of the villain for a good part of his life. Then he meets AoA Jean and his perspective start to change. We get to see that, deep down, he is very similar to 616 Scott. But we still regard him as a version of 616 Scott, right?
I think it would be the same if we changed the 616 characters. They'd probably still be recognisable, but they'd be a version of themselves.
I hope this makes some sense...
Exactly. Or the many many characters in hollywood who have been race bent with no problem to be white. But hey i'm just trying to let people live their truth.
Just like immigrants, to answer one question there are jamaican immigrants, spanish, the list goes on. people be acting like we damn blind. lol\
Last edited by jwatson; 09-07-2021 at 02:38 AM.
Don't let anyone else hold the candle that lights the way to your future because only you can sustain the flame.
Number of People on my ignore list: 0
#conceptualthinking ^_^
#ByeMarvEN
Into the breach.
https://www.instagram.com/jartist27/
It would make them belong to a different race or gender.
What I was trying to say is that any of those changes affects the character internally. Maybe as readers we won't see it very often and it won't be obvious to us, because we look at them (especially nowadays) from an outside perspective. But given a certain circumstance, the character would/should react differently if they have a different gender or race (and if the writer is thinking of them as if they were a real person).
The way I see it, like a real person, the characters should be the product of both their background and their experiences. Some things have more impact than others, but they all matter, they're all part of whole.
You change some stuff of the character (not through development, experiences, learning, etc...) and you change the character. They might still be recognisable, but they're a version of the original, just like an AU version can be recognisable.
I think making some of the O5 minorities would make them more relatable in 2021, especially considering the whole mutant allegory for historically disenfranchised or oppressed groups. My belief is that having Cyclops (and Alex) be Mexican-American, for example, would make him more sympathetic to audiences and add depth to his struggles… the feeling of alienation, insecurity, etc., as he ultimately steps up and becomes the de facto leader of the X-men at a young age. Plus the MCU seems to be seriously lacking in the Hispanic demographic, especially considering they’re approaching 20% of the U.S. population. I look at a guy like Diego Boneta, who is 30 years old, and think he’d make a good Scott Summers. And you don’t even have to change his name. Just have his mother be Mexican and father a white U.S. Air Force captain, Christopher Summers. But I can see flashback scenes where the kids in school or around the military base where he grew up are picking on him, and poking at his heritage becomes a part of that abuse.
I also think Iceman could be not only gay but also a minority, perhaps black, and maybe Beast is an American Pacific Islander (Samoan, Tongan, Hawaiian). Angel and Jean I’d probably leave as white because, well, their whiteness (and privilege) could be an important part of their characters and also juxtaposition against the other three. Because, despite being mutants, they’ve always fit in. At least up until their powers manifested. And now they also know what it’s like to be discriminated against. Could be interesting I think.
At any rate, I’m typically not for race-bending for the sake of race-bending (i.e., I prefer them to just use existing minority characters instead), but I think these changes would be for the better honestly and add depth to the O5 and to the franchise as a whole.
Last edited by Jackraow21; 09-07-2021 at 06:04 AM.
Again, I agree. Take the original five X-Men, for example. They grew up during the 1960s, during a time of great racial discrimination. Thus, changing the race - and this includes to Black, Latino, Asian, Native American, and any other race - of either of the original five would fundamentally change their experiences and perspectives, which, in turn, would change their personalities. Additionally, if we consider how one's race affected one's station in life during the aforementioned era, how likely would it be that most of the original five would have come from affluent families, as did Warren, Bobby, and Jean? Not likely, I don't think, which would further change their experiences and perspectives.
In either case, claiming that nothing or very little about a character would change if their race or sex were changed requires overlooking a lot, including the details and nuances that distinguish and make that character who they are. I created this thread, in part, to explore the changes that would occur if a character's sex and/or race were changed, knowing full well that a lot would change for each character presented. I did not intend for this discussion to devolve into each of us presenting reasons why these changes should not be made to our favorite characters, which is beside the point of the question posed.