Trial of the Amazons in 2022

[Primal Slayer]

Wondergirl didn’t fail it was beautiful and intresting. It was also posting numbers better then WW has done herself in years. It had to transition into this crossover to be ready for the upcoming summer event.

It should. It's a brand new #1 with top art.

[Gaius]

Wondergirl didn’t fail it was beautiful and intresting. It was also posting numbers better then WW has done herself in years. It had to transition into this crossover to be ready for the upcoming summer event.

It was cancelled at eight issues despite being solicited as ongoing. By this same logic, Jon Kent Son of Kal-El and Jace should have had their books cancelled to "transition" into Dark Crisis (lol).

It was also dull and it's writer/artist couldn't keep up with the schedule.

[WonderLight789]

Wondergirl didn’t fail it was beautiful and intresting. It was also posting numbers better then WW has done herself in years. It had to transition into this crossover to be ready for the upcoming summer event.

Most of those WW titles mentioned didn't even fail commercially. The new WG started to decline in sales pretty fast. Current WW still has had better sales than what yara showed at her peak. So.

[Koriand'r]

It was cancelled at eight issues despite being solicited as ongoing. By this same logic, Jon Kent Son of Kal-El and Jace should have had their books cancelled to "transition" into Dark Crisis (lol).

It was also dull and it's writer/artist couldn't keep up with the schedule.

This is exactly what I'm talking about, there was nothing "dull" about Wonder Girl but there's still an insistence by some to try and convince us that's the case. There's no way it could be called that with Yara's fiery personality and Joelle Jones' beautiful art, but for whatever reasons some are trying to make it a thing. That's why I say we're hard to please.

[Koriand'r]

If you think Yara Flor threatens Wonder Woman just say that, but don't piss on my leg and tell me it's rain.

[Alpha]

Most of those WW titles mentioned didn't even fail commercially. The new WG started to decline in sales pretty fast. Current WW still has had better sales than what yara showed at her peak. So.

Hum what? That's not true at all but whatever.

And it's obvious that the delays are what killed it.

I'll never understand the hate for Yara Flor. The book had bad plot development but it was tons of fun and gave lots of love to Cassie Sandsmark too

[Primal Slayer]

Yeah I've enjoyed Yara. I just dislike that she has next to 0 connection to Diana.

[Gaius]

This is exactly what I'm talking about, there was nothing "dull" about Wonder Girl but there's still an insistence by some to try and convince us that's the case. There's no way it could be called that with Yara's fiery personality and Joelle Jones' beautiful art, but for whatever reasons some are trying to make it a thing. That's why I say we're hard to please.

You did not find the book dull. I did. I shared my opinion, not trying to convince anyone of anything.

As I said, it's a matter of preference.

[WonderLight789]

Hum what? That's not true at all but whatever.

And it's obvious that the delays are what killed it.

I'll never understand the hate for Yara Flor. The book had bad plot development but it was tons of fun and gave lots of love to Cassie Sandsmark too

It is true. Did yara had sales as good as WW with the trasdes from Truth and Lies for example? or her anniversary issue. Or Historia, or the novel by warbringer? The truth is she didn't.

[Alpha]

It is true. Did yara had sales as good as WW with the trasdes from Truth and Lies for example? or her anniversary issue. Or Historia, or the novel by warbringer? The truth is she didn't.

We have no idea how many issues she sold bro. DC doesn't reveal numbers anymore. What we know is that she was outselling Wonder Woman when it came out (which yes is to be expected from a new series, and I'm not dissing Wonder Woman)

[Stanlos]

It was cancelled at eight issues despite being solicited as ongoing. By this same logic, Jon Kent Son of Kal-El and Jace should have had their books cancelled to "transition" into Dark Crisis (lol).

It was also dull and it's writer/artist couldn't keep up with the schedule.

That really wasn't on the artist though. That was TPTB meddling, going back on their word, and interfering.

[Primal Slayer]

That really wasn't on the artist though. That was TPTB meddling, going back on their word, and interfering.

...what was their word?

[Gaelforce]

Okay, let's watch it with the gatekeeping style posts.

Everyone's opinion (so long as it is presented in a civil manner) is welcome here.

If you disagree with someone, that's fine, but no one should be declaring another person's opinion as invalid just because it conflicts with your own.

You may love a story, someone else may hate a story and that's why there's chocolate and vanilla. Declaring that only chocolate is good, or that if you don't like vanilla then you're not really a fan is not wanted here or anywhere else on the forum for that matter.

[9th.]

Alright everyone let's look at our track record for a minute.

War of the Gods - fail
Amazons Attack - fail
Wonder Woman Darkest Night - fail
Wonder Woman The Odyssey - fail
Wonder Woman the New 52 - fail
Superman/Wonder Woman - fail
Wonder Woman Future's End - fail
Convergence Wonder Woman - fail
Dark Nights Death Metal - fail
Wonder Woman Dead Earth - fail
Wonder Woman Evolution - fail
Future State Wonder Woman - fail
Wonder Girl - fail
Trial of the Amazons -

D.C. tries hard to do something with Wonder Woman we will like and so often it's met with a luke warm response at best and outright disdain at worst. The only recent things I can think of that the majoity of us enjoy are the Legend of Wonder Woman and to a lesser extent Wonder Woman Black and Gold. Hell there are actually people who dislike Rebirth. How could you dislike Rebirth?

At some point after several failed relationships you have to ask yourself if it's them, or is it you.

What makes Dead Earth a fail? Did it have super low sales or something?

[Gaius]

What makes Dead Earth a fail? Did it have super low sales or something?

First two issues debuted around #50 and #70, last two came out after DC left Diamond so hard to track how well those sold. No idea on the trade.

Depends on what DC considers a success or failure though.