Completely agree, its like he read summaries rather the actual issues.
Emma and Scott disagreed on Utopia and disagreed on the approach to Hope/Phoenix with Emma wanting to give Hope the choice.
It was Starks stupidity that forced the Phoenix Force on the P5
Its the same with IvX the editors decided to shelve Emma for a year and a half then saddle her with Scotts burden despite them ending pretty badly in Bendis run. That X-Office Editorial has yet to be overhauled.