‘new’ Iron Fist. Why???

[bretmaverick2]

I like Danny Rand. I like Danny as Iron Fist. I don’t see why they are sacrificing his role just to make an ethnic correction.

First, is Marvel saying white people can’t have martial arts skill? Is it racist that they believe all martial art lead characters should be Asian?

I would rather they developed an ALL NEW original character If they wanted more Asian representation.

I feel like Marvel is promoting an Asian stereotype.

[PlatinumThorns]

It's less about the martial arts aspect of the character and more like the cultural background of the Iron Fist. I'm not personally a fan of the character so I don't care either way, but it's probably a good solution until Danny becomes a 'different' version of the Iron Fist.

[ed2962]

This is just temporary. We've seen this play out multiple times in just the last several years alone. It's not worth getting upset over. Danny isn't going anywhere.

[Spiderfan001]

Because legacy characters are all the rage and even though we all know they won't last and the OG's will be back they'll take the minor sales boost instead of writing a good comic....

[Omega Alpha]

Because legacy characters are all the rage and even though we all know they won't last and the OG's will be back they'll take the minor sales boost instead of writing a good comic....

Yeah, pretty much. Not much to be worked over. A few years down the road they'll make a "Return of the Iron Fist" story.

[protege]

I like Danny Rand. I like Danny as Iron Fist. I don’t see why they are sacrificing his role just to make an ethnic correction.

First, is Marvel saying white people can’t have martial arts skill? Is it racist that they believe all martial art lead characters should be Asian?

I would rather they developed an ALL NEW original character If they wanted more Asian representation.

I feel like Marvel is promoting an Asian stereotype.

Oddly enough, wasn't the guy who's assuming the mantle an original character?

[Wat]

Cuz the old one is trash in Marvel's opinion!

[scourge]

Oddly enough, wasn't the guy who's assuming the mantle an original character?

It seems like its going to be an existing character switching their ID to Iron Fist.

[Tofali]

Honestly in the long run this will work better for Danny if the IP balanced out the optics by having the Iron Fist mantle being led by an Asian characters then having them all team-up

[OpaqueGiraffe17]

I don't have a horse in this race, but its probably for whats more convenient for the movies. I'm guess theres a decent chance they'll introduce an iron fist in a future shang-chi movie. And they'll probably want keep to the trend of a mostly asian cast.

[protege]

It seems like its going to be an existing character switching their ID to Iron Fist.

Yeah, but when he started out, nobody heard of him.

[JudicatorPrime]

I thought the whole point of the Iron Fist was for there always to be a line of succession -- meaning Rand wasn't the first Iron Fist, nor will he be the last. Is that not the case?

Honestly, after watching the Shang Chi & the 10 rings movie, I honestly thought Marvel missed an opportunity. They should have made Shang Chi the Iron Fist of the MCU. I wasn't a fan of the Mandarin replacing Fu Manchu as Shang's father. But if they were going to do that, they might as well let the Great Protector dragon be a guise of Shou-Lao the Undying and give Shang and/or his sister (speaking of which, what happened to M'Nai, Shang's brother???) the powers of the IF. But whatever.

[Username taken]

I thought the whole point of the Iron Fist was for there always to be a line of succession -- meaning Rand wasn't the first Iron Fist, nor will he be the last. Is that not the case?

Honestly, after watching the Shang Chi & the 10 rings movie, I honestly thought Marvel missed an opportunity. They should have made Shang Chi the Iron Fist of the MCU. I wasn't a fan of the Mandarin replacing Fu Manchu as Shang's father. But if they were going to do that, they might as well let the Great Protector dragon be a guise of Shou-Lao the Undying and give Shang and/or his sister (speaking of which, what happened to M'Nai, Shang's brother???) the powers of the IF. But whatever.

The bolded is correct.

Danny Rand isn't the first Iron Fist but the latest in a long line of them. I suspect that was Fraction trying to address the cultural issues around the Iron Fist.

To be clear, the cultural issues around Iron Fist being a white man isn't new...at all. https://bleedingcool.com/comics/comp...agonists-1974/. It's not a product of "modern day thinking", it's always been there. We have to keep it 100 around these issues or else we lose perspective.

I suspect the young man is the latest in the Iron Fist line. Him being Asian is also a good thing because when Marvel want to produce an Iron Fist movie or tv show, it avoids the racial complaints around the character.

[9th.]

I thought the whole point of the Iron Fist was for there always to be a line of succession -- meaning Rand wasn't the first Iron Fist, nor will he be the last. Is that not the case?

Honestly, after watching the Shang Chi & the 10 rings movie, I honestly thought Marvel missed an opportunity. They should have made Shang Chi the Iron Fist of the MCU. I wasn't a fan of the Mandarin replacing Fu Manchu as Shang's father. But if they were going to do that, they might as well let the Great Protector dragon be a guise of Shou-Lao the Undying and give Shang and/or his sister (speaking of which, what happened to M'Nai, Shang's brother???) the powers of the IF. But whatever.

Nah I'm glad they didn't make Shang the Iron Fist, I like that he has his own thing going on. MCU made him look much cooler than Netflix Danny anyway.

[Xheight]

I thought the whole point of the Iron Fist was for there always to be a line of succession -- meaning Rand wasn't the first Iron Fist, nor will he be the last. Is that not the case?

Honestly, after watching the Shang Chi & the 10 rings movie, I honestly thought Marvel missed an opportunity. They should have made Shang Chi the Iron Fist of the MCU. I wasn't a fan of the Mandarin replacing Fu Manchu as Shang's father. But if they were going to do that, they might as well let the Great Protector dragon be a guise of Shou-Lao the Undying and give Shang and/or his sister (speaking of which, what happened to M'Nai, Shang's brother???) the powers of the IF. But whatever.

Have followed the character for years from and loved that they developed that succession thing so if there have been asians in the past now can make sense too provided they kill off Danny. Didn't see the movie so I can't comment but the Comic Shang Chi seemed limited in comparison over the years to IF. Bring back Fu Manchu and they might have something but that is a copyright thing and hence the Yellow Claw/Mandarin thing.