Trial of Magneto #4 Preview

[gurkle]

If I can say one thing that's sort of in Williams' defense, some of what's wrong with this series could have been fixed if she'd had better dialogue editing. The dialogue and narration are so wordy they make Claremont seem concise*, but they don't have to be, every speech balloon and caption could have said the same thing in half the space.

Editors are supposed to go through these scripts and get the writer to cut down the dialogue and polish it. I'm sure this isn't a first draft, but it feels like one and it's not the first Marvel book in the last few years that makes me feel that way. They need more editors on fewer books.

*Actually, Claremont was pretty concise sometimes, he just had a lot of things to talk about.

[Noek]

Magneto Should Still Be Scarlet Witch's Father, And Marvel Knows It
https://screenrant.com/magneto-scarl...etcon-mistake/

Bit of a stupid article with no mention of Wanda's series at the start of ANAD which did go into their parentage, because this whole thing is Marvel didn't do anything with it. In fact screenrant did mention they have a bad relationship so why not let them fly free.

[CJStriker]

I hope this issue makes sense. Last one was very confusing

Last one was the Weakest out of the 3 Issues, was more of a set-up for this 4th issue IMO but still did not excuse the lacking of the issue I felt it has right away after reading it.

Issues 1 and 2 Left me please with some major good moments IMO and wanting more, 3 was a big letdown.

From the Teases of issue 4, it seems much better with more meat to it, but it is WAY to early to speculate if it will hit better or not, it has a better decent edge IMO in the previews then when the previews came out for issue 3, so at least getting the feels I had previews for 3 it paned out how I felt it would, so if 4 does the same it has hopes in being better, but still have to wait and read it.

Looks like it leaked or something? Some screens of the issue being posted on Twitter right now, there are some uh weird ones but better wait to read the whole thing instead of taking it out of context I guess?

Pages out of context are always weird not matter what, hard to say if anything is good or not just from them. Like I said uptop they have a better feel to them then anything from 3, more meat for story and major points at least, but indeed wait until one reads it to get the true picture, don't judge until full taken in it the best philosophy to any book. Trailer speculating will drive anyone up the walls, LOL.

[Shadowcat]

This has become progressively worse with each issue. I understand this was an editorially mandated mini, but Leah could only come up with this? Marvel should have given this to Steve Orlando.

[Shadowcat]

I hope this issue makes sense. Last one was very confusing

I’m a reviewer for a comic site, and have glanced at it. It’s not.

[Journey]

I feel I'm gonna like this issue no matter what through in Billy & I'm pleased, Billy & Tommy together hell yeah I'm gonna love it. Plot is a secondary thing for me lmao

[CJStriker]

This has become progressively worse with each issue. I understand this was an editorially mandated mini, but Leah could only come up with this? Marvel should have given this to Steve Orlando.

I’m a reviewer for a comic site, and have glanced at it. It’s not.

I feel I'm gonna like this issue no matter what through in Billy & I'm pleased, Billy & Tommy together hell yeah I'm gonna love it. Plot is a secondary thing for me lmao

Choices where made for the writer Shadowcatand Leah was the choice, I am not a Reviewer by any stretch of life but I still rather give Leah the benefiter of the doubt and read what she put down full in both this and issue 5 until I can full grasp my view on the story, right now IMO Issues 1-2 where good while 3 was not, 4-5 can bring it all together and around like others have but we have to wait to read fully if that is the case.

I also era on the side of Journey as well more times then not, I find things I like more in books then dislike and take those as points I like getting out of the story both moments from Wanda and from others as well that stick with me(Jean Hugging Vision in Issue #2 is a Major one for me), I will see what 4 and finally what 5 gives to us in the end and what I and others will take away from it.

[Bunch of Coconuts]

I feel I'm gonna like this issue no matter what through in Billy & I'm pleased, Billy & Tommy together hell yeah I'm gonna love it. Plot is a secondary thing for me lmao

Not at all surprising.

[Mercury]

Are we allowed to post a link to a Twitter thread containing major spoilers?

Also, I’m not enthused…

[CoCoBandz]

Are we allowed to post a link to a Twitter thread containing major spoilers?

Also, I’m not enthused…

DM's. I wanna see.

[PhoenixThanos]

Are we allowed to post a link to a Twitter thread containing major spoilers?

Also, I’m not enthused…

Yes please, just put spoiler at the top and scroll down half a page.

[Wolverine12]

Are we allowed to post a link to a Twitter thread containing major spoilers?

Also, I’m not enthused…

No don’t post it. DM’s are fine.

[Mercury]

Yes please, just put spoiler at the top and scroll down half a page.

I’m scared to. ������

But you and CoCo can check your DMs now.

[MexM]

Pages out of context are always weird not matter what, hard to say if anything is good or not just from them. Like I said uptop they have a better feel to them then anything from 3, more meat for story and major points at least, but indeed wait until one reads it to get the true picture, don't judge until full taken in it the best philosophy to any book. Trailer speculating will drive anyone up the walls, LOL.

Yup, agreed with that philosophy.

[CJStriker]

Are we allowed to post a link to a Twitter thread containing major spoilers?

Also, I’m not enthused…

I’m scared to. ������

But you and CoCo can check your DMs now.

For your safety Mercury I would not, it is to early and even in spoiler tags for it to be this early I don't think it would be per the board policies or a good idea, even if I am wrong I rather not see anything happen to you , we can wait till the right time tomorrow.