Movie versions of the Fellowship and some others vs some horror movie weirdos!

Frodo
Sam
Pippin
Merry
Boromir
Aragorn
Legolas
Gimli
Gandalf (The White)
Gollum
Eomer, Theoden, and Eowyn all on Horseback
Haldir
Faramir
Lurtz (Uruk-Hai who dueled Aragorn for a bit and had a bow)
Tauriel
Elrond

vs

Jason Vorhees
Michael Myers
Ghostface
Gabriel (Malignant): Feats 1, 2 with his knife
The Dog from The Thing
Pyramidhead from the Silent Hill movie: Feat 1 (Note: gory)
A werewolf from Dog Soldiers: Feats
The Fly (The Fly)
The lead vampire from 30 Days of Night and a generic other vampire: Feats 1, 2
The Predator from Predator (no ranged weapons)
A xenomorph
A velociraptor from Jurassic Park

Takes place in the Shire but emptied of all inhabitants