See, I agree with this. It just takes more than just beat 'em ups and stats to make a memorable story.
So stats only matter when you say so. Got it.
Okay, so let's give her a reason to be memorable. That said, while I love Catwoman, I haven't seen this new animated movie (probably won't until it appears on HBOMax). I can honestly say that her defeating Cheetah does not make me think any better of her. Nor would it have me think any better of Cheetah had it turned out the other way around. Anyone can write a story where one character can beat up another. Writing a story where I actually care about a character enough for me to want them to win? That takes skill.
I agree, which is why I find him/it to be a boring character. Literally, his entire claim to fame is that he killed Superman once. The writers themselves admitted they had no idea where to take the character after doing that.
Actually, if you've read the Superman/Batman arc where they reintroduced Supergirl/Kara into the modern era, you'd see otherwise. Not saying that makes it right, but it just goes along with my point that nobody cares about Doomsday enough to care that he wins.
I agree. But character moments generally lead to better stories. And better stories generally lead to a character like Cheetah being treated the way you want her to.
Last edited by phonogram12; 02-18-2022 at 12:43 PM.
Keep in mind that you have about as much chance of changing my mind as I do of changing yours.
I think a lot of writers still think of Superfriends when they think of Cheetah and probably dont even realize she's a different character whose been "blessed" by a god to amplify her powers. They see her as someone whose superhuman but not SUPER human.
Keep in mind that you have about as much chance of changing my mind as I do of changing yours.
Not in this case. First you need to re do a long history of Cheetah being known as a weaklink in almost everyfight that isn't against WW. The most basic of her character is supposed to be a formidable powerful opponent and they don't even get that right and affect WW's own reputation as a result.
Patty Jenkins couldn't create a proper action-powerhouse film even if her life depended on it. So nobody should be surprised. This is why most WW villains will suffer under her. She is not suited for good action and battle scenes. And a lore like WW is supposed to have that. If she could have her way both WW films would have ended with no epic battle moment. And that can work for one film. But you can't have a lore like WW and never get into the power, action spectacle side of her world. Cheetah needed a strong debut. She needed that badly. And jenkins and johns truly let her down. Sad
Because Barbara Minerva isn't the most important female villain