Can we make a list of the known murderers allowed to roam free on New Krakoa?

[Wolverine12]

I’d disagree on the virtues that I think there is an objective right and wrong and people of sound mind who are morally wrong are still morally wrong even though they think they’re right. So, in such cases, it doesn’t matter if they think what they’re doing is right. Particularly when you get into evil. Like Hitler, if we want to use the clearest case of agreement. So, I guess what I’m saying is, don’t overthink it. Logan killing Nazi soldiers in World War II is different from Apocalypse killing random people. And when it comes to duress, I would limit it to smaller scale cases that are few and far between.

Your op didn’t mention anything about morality of said killings. That’s my point. Let be honest with ourselves this isn’t the first time a thread like this has popped up to show the moral ambiguities displayed by Krakoa, but by your criteria morality isn’t a factor in this case.

The list of mutants that have killed for just pleasure or random violence isn’t very long when we apply these filters.

[H-E-D]

Murder has always had a narrow definition (as opposed to the more general killing) going back to ancient times. I am honestly quite surprised at the disconnect.

The definition of a murderer is defined as "having been convicted of the crime of murder". I don't think that many characters have been convicted by courts.

[H-E-D]

Can we make a list of the known murderers allowed to roam free in the United States of America?

[Rift]

Maybe it'll help if we make a list of mutants who HAVEN'T killed people. I'll start.

Hellion

[BobbysWorld]

Maybe it'll help if we make a list of mutants who HAVEN'T killed people. I'll start.

Hellion

Ummm Rift, are you saying Hellion is NOT a canon-confirmed ladykiller? Does HE know that?

[Rift]

Ummm Rift, are you saying Hellion is NOT a canon-confirmed ladykiller? Does HE know that?

Contrary to the title, he doesn't ACTUALLY kill them. He just sends them to Heaven.

[Ambaryerno]

Maybe it'll help if we make a list of mutants who HAVEN'T killed people. I'll start.

Hellion

Only because of a retcon. When he killed Karima it was intended to be just that.

[Zelena]

The definition of a murderer is defined as "having been convicted of the crime of murder". I don't think that many characters have been convicted by courts.

Except Magneto, few mutants are sent to courts… even if they deserve it. It is like a separate society, even before Krakoa.

But then, in comics with super-heroes, villains are stopped and punished by super-heroes… There, super-heroes are much less super-heroes because they work with villains…

Hickman’s run has no figure who could represent moral compass…

[BobbysWorld]

Only because of a retcon. When he killed Karima it was intended to be just that.

Julian's gonna be such an unbearably smug bitch when he finds out he could have single-handedly saved all of mutantkind from the eventual threat of Orchis if they hadn't gotten in his way when he tried to kill her in his Trauma Response Era.

[BroHomo]

stop snitching

Thiiis lol

[Nicoclaws]

Julian's gonna be such an unbearably smug bitch when he finds out he could have single-handedly saved all of mutantkind from the eventual threat of Orchis if they hadn't gotten in his way when he tried to kill her in his Trauma Response Era.

Oooooh ! So Rift would have been right all along ! The endgame WAS Hellion !

[Triniking1234]

Bobby froze & killed 100's of thousands of people during a mid-life gay panic crisis. He got nothing but a slap on the wrist & a dirty look from She-Hulk.

That stuck? I thought they got better. lmao.

[Triniking1234]

Robots can be an interesting question. Sentient aliens should totally count though, even if hostile. That begs the question of animal-like aliens like the Brood, actually. Same thing for the Warwolves.

Listen. If I'm at a family BBQ and Shi'Ar show up to kill me, they all dying that day.

Rogue killed Grim Reaper. but nobody cares about him

Fake news. Williams committed suicide.

[Nicoclaws]

Listen. If I'm at a family BBQ and Shi'Ar show up to kill me, they all dying that day.

Still killing a sentient person. In self defence though so it's apparently ok ?

I don't remember the Grim Reaper thing, honestly - but I remember the Goth, and that says a lot about my appreciation of Rick Remender.

[Technopriest]

The members of both incarnations of the Balack Ops versions of X-Force have killed, so Warpath, Wolfsbane, Archangel, X-23, Psylocke, Domino, and Wolverine.