Duggan has successfully baited me with the Scott and Emma content. Here I go foolishly getting my hopes up.
I think so too,in a way it was written into the X-Men calculus.They safeguard their survival with the protocols full well knowing the CoV already have a mechanism to regenerate their kind, while regular humans, once this secret is out will follow suit which would likely mean transhumanism becoming a reality within decades not a century or so.So trying to put the genie back in the bottle, as it were, by negating the protocols could be the option taken. It would take more than shelving the protocols and probably wouldn't be enough but we'll just have to wait and see.
As someone fascinated with the idea of transhumanism, particularly in a cyberpunk context where transhuman technologies ultimately end up being used to further calcify existing social inequities by turning those with the wealth and/or other means to obtain and exploit such technologies into an effectively immortal superhuman overclass, the aftermath of the Protocols being revealed to the world sounds about as expected.
The spider is always on the hunt.
The genre also offers a lot of examples where the whole aspect of immortality through cloning and memory recording/downloading can go horrible wrong or lead to a massive social and cultural decline.
And here we have the additional factor of laws of physics breaking super powers.
One thing i had to remember pretty early, especialy when the neglect of mutant children and youths became a larger topic in New Mutants and later Way of X, was the Battle Angel Alita follow up manga Last Order, where the reader could finaly see the state the rest of the solar system was in (the original only mentioned that there had been a large war which has resulted in Earth becomming an isolated scavenger world).
Among this was the reveal that long ago a young hacker had gained access to a secret technology which allows to stop the aging process. Being the idealistic "information need to be free" type activist, he simply revealed this information to all of humanity, making it commonplace and unrestricted.
Which had horrible consequences for the value and treatment of children in many of the societies.
Yeah I hear you, humans getting access to this technology will not mean some egalitarian immortality ,far from it.It will be a privilege of the few with the wealth and technology to create a super class. So shelving the protocols is too little too late as Orchis,Xeno and Stasis probably have similar or fully reverse engineered programmes,the only difference is the framing is X-Men don't want technological peers as this from their p.o.v is an existential threat, yet they at least apparently initiate this immortality arms race.
Between this and the stuff previewed for the next run on Spidey I fear for the wallcrawler. First they screw over his relationship with MJ now the Moira Jane now...what I'm going to assume is probably the Jackal coming back since the resurrection protocols in all but name.
Or hell, maybe another Osborn has become a demon and decided to screw with the X-men for once.
I mean as much as I'd enjoy transhumanism (which was essentially the original Hickman plan it sounds like, just a fight over what flavor of transhumanity..and I for one am eternally disapointed magic was not represented), Marvel was not going to
A). Change the world status quo that much if the real life technology is not that close.
B). Not let events in the X-office dictate how the entire future of the Marvel universe goes. X-men isn't quite at mid-nineties level of controlling everything at Marvel again.
Only a handful of characters got blurbs in the official guide. "Prominent role"?
"Danielle... I intend to do something rash and violent." - Betsy Braddock
Krakoa, Arakko, and Otherworld forever!
Honestly why would Jackal even care about that tech? His cloning method only has the flaw of the carrion killing you without the pills, even then that got fixed, why would he care about transferable memories? Unless he was planning to make a clone of himself in a stronger body or somethin'...
Orchis doesn't care about humans, they care about killing mutants.That's just off the top of my head, and considering Orchis does have a Sinister doppelganger working for/with them under the guise of Doctor Stasis . . . why don't they offer their own resurrective technology to the general human populace?
At the very least, his cloning method has actual proper explanations, while other cloning methods just work.
In-universe though, there should be nothing special about the cloning method Hickman came up with, if anything it's needlessly convoluted compared to what Sinister can do on a weekend when he's bored lol.
The stuff that could make the cloning method standout more, like putting someone's mind in another body, or resurrecting someone to not be as old, are either hardly done, or not done at all.
My guess is the Gwen that shows up in Eternals has something to do with those changes, whether or not she'll remain alive is anyone's guess though.
Have X-Men also used this though? I only remember Spidey's side making confirmations about this (Silk's tie-in to Clone Conspiracy having her ghost boyfriend forcefully be put back in a living body, Ben's Scarlet Spider comic having Death herself say she's the actual Ben, and ASM having Dr. Strange say that Connors' son, Billy, has the same soul), but I'm not sure if that's confirmed to be widespread.
Then again, given how many times every major mutants has died, might as well say it is indeed the case, even if there are logical flaws here and there, but hey...