Originally Posted by
Kpop
If it were simply a case of Disney whitewashing one of Marvel's most well-known all-Asian super-teams for their movie, that would be one thing. I would still have issues with it, but I'd also still see the Disney version and probably enjoy it as its own thing, because I'm capable of accepting two differing artistic interpretations of a property. How the Disney race equation exactly works is beyond me. I'd be interested in seeing the marketing/profitability calculation that goes: "6 Asian lead characters wouldn't be marketable to a worldwide audience, but 1.5 Asian lead characters feels just right" . . . and all this in an age where a tree and a raccoon are the most popular characters in one of the summer's biggest comic book blockbusters. If the heroes are written with heart and character, then their appeal should be able to transcend their skin color and become identifiable with people of all creeds and colors. But, like I said before, I would still go and see the Disney movie, try to forget about the whitewashing, and enjoy it own its own merits.
However, what's especially heinous in the case of Big Hero 6 is that Disney has not only whitewashed the original Asian team, but prevented any further publications of the original Asian team. Disney/whitewashed Big Hero 6 is effectively erasing and supplanting Marvel/Japanese Big Hero 6. In the event that a new Big Hero 6 fan really enjoys the movie and wants to see the comics by which the movie was inspired, he/she is out of luck because there will be no reprints of the old issues made available. For the Marvel fan who appreciated Big Hero 6's status as one of the only Marvel super-hero properties to feature an all-Asian cast and get as many as two limited series and a handful of guest appearances since 1998, she/he is out of luck because the whitewashed Disney version of Big Hero 6 is now the only game in town.
It'd be like if, prior to the release of "Frozen," Disney bought the rights to Hans Christian Andersen's "The Snow Queen" and prohibited any future reprints of the collection for fear that moviegoers would be confused by two different interpretations of the same story.
I could have handled two versions of Big Hero 6. It's Disney that couldn't.