Originally Posted by
Omega Alpha
That's because:
1) A natural consequence of this move would be to increase the pressure on the Quiet Council to eventually develop into a fully fledged democracy elected by the Krakoan people rather than a bunch of aristocrats chosen by themselves, but Marvel isn't interested in moving away from it any time soon, partially because most writers and editors almost certainly would have no idea how to make that transition, part because they want to milk the premise as much as they can;
Mind you, I really like Immortal X-men and I don't mind it continuing, but it is a book that should come with an expiration date and later be changed to something very different.
2) Another natural consequence would be a gradual move to a more political and militant Cyclops, like in the Decimation/Utopia era, as his moves anger the dominant aristocracy of the QC while nothing much changes, and because people would eventually notice they can chose their X-men, but not their political leaders (it was pretty obvious Hickman was going somewhat that way eventually: he was going to give Scott everything he ever wanted in Krakoa- family, Jean back, but having Emma on the side as well, peace of mind, etc, only to have it shattered when the dark deals that made Krakoa are revealed and the status quo moves to something else very different, and we would see Scott's reaction to all that)
The problem is that JDW already made it clear he HATES, HATES, HATES that version of the character and he's not alone at Marvel. From describing Gillen's UXM as a Brotherhood book, to how much he loves Schism, for Rosenberg's run being clearly designed as a **** you to anyone that loved Cyclops and Emma relationship and anything that happened with the characters from Morrison to 2019, etc, while we know for a fact Marvel was shocked most people sided with Cyclops both in Schism and specially AvX, with fans yelling how Cyclops was right at conventions, etc. JDW himself has been on these boards on quite a few occasions arguing with fans (myself included) usually about this very period or Rosenberg's terrible run.
Then they decided to double down it by having being Scott killed off panel and being described as the mutant Hitler, and only did a U-turn after the Inhumans thing crash and burned, but still already in Krakoa era the History of the Marvel Universe thing, edited by Breevort (the architect of AvX) had Utopia being described as a fascist dictatorship.
So, they can't have a book that explores the consequences of a challenge to Krakoan status quo because it would result in changes they are unwilling to make, and also because many people are Marvel are still butthurt people didn't like their bad stories and didn't want Cyclops back to how he was decades before because they don't share their obsession with keeping the status quo like it was in their childhoods, and they can't have a truly satisfying classic superhero book because it doesn't really fit the present era, so I don't see it becoming a much better book.