WEEK 17 "WHO'S COOKIN' ON THE HOTSEAT?/FIRE THIS COACH!" DISCUSSION
(ALREADY FIRED BEFORE WEEK 6): Matt Ruhle (Panthers), Frank Reich (Colts) FIRED! THEY’RE FIRED!
10. Todd Bowles, Buccaneers: I’ve personally rooted for Todd Bowles since he was Bruce Arians’ DC in Arizona, and getting a coaching job with the Jets was a near death sentence for the man’s career. Still, he went back to Tampa Bay and got a ring working as DC under Arians there when Tom Brady walked through the door. This is his first year in his second stint as a head coach and…
Things do not look as predestined for the Bucs at the moment, as they lead what currently is the worst division in football at 6-8. Yes, were it not for how awful the Saints, Falcons, and Panthers are, Tampa Bay would likely be out of the playoffs entirely. Their offensive line is a patchwork of reserves in for guys out with injuries, and Brady’s marital problems with Gisele were a distraction through the first half of the year, but week to week, Brady has been as emotionally unstable than he’s ever been on any sideline, ever, with him chucking tablets and berating his own offensive linemen for giving up too many sacks. It’s not a good look for a franchise that looked like they would be atop the league as long as the were running the GOAT out there.
Sunday, Brady had 2 INTs and 2 lost fumbles, to help trigger a 17 point comeback at the hands of Joe Burrow and the Bengals. The Creamsicle Crew just have not locked up this division with three weeks to play, and Bowles is reportedly “under review” by the Glazer family right now. Brady is a free agent again after this year, and there are postulators predicting a reunion with Belichik in New England.
But, there’s hope for Bowles to get his team to finish with a winning record, as next week they’ll be playing the Arizona Cardinals while they are likely to field Trace McSorley at QB, and then they play with Carolina running out Sam Darnold and his mononucleosis, before finishing the season at Atlanta, who are, in theory, spinning the tires on rookie Desmond Ridder. If Tom Brady manages to take this mediocre team into the playoffs on the benefit of sucking less than every other team in the NFC South, and pull a first round upset, Bowles will have justified he knows what he’s doing… but that’s a big IF right now.
9. Sean McVay, Rams : The coach of the defending champs. Sure, they’re 4-10, mostly because they let a lot of talent depart from the offensive line and didn’t replace it, as well as two Pro Bowlers in Von Miller and OBJ without doing much to replace them… and they’ve traded away all their high draft picks until like 2025 or something… so maybe their championship window slammed shut right after they pulled the Lombardi trophy through it. Can you blame Sean McVay for Les Snead’s plan for a title getting done, and then the consequences of how they did it coming this hard and fast?
I’m gonna be clear. Sean McVay is a coach who’s owned his division the past several years. He coached Jared Goff into being at least a respectable QB after being miserable when he arrived. He’s got an eidetic memory, and knows every play call he’s ever made in every situation like you are I are just reciting our phone numbers. Injuries and front office management have made this year be even more than he can handle, and I haven’t even gotten into Matt Stafford exploding into a thousand injury-pieces at the same time after finally getting a ring…
But I think Sean McVay is going to be done in Los Angeles after this season. Not because he sucks, or he’s getting fired… I just think he’s going to “pull a Madden” and take that steel trap of a mind to a broadcast booth while he’s young, and get paid stupid amounts of money with infinitely less stress in his gig.
Plus, y’know, he’s a year removed from a title, and it would be weird to FIRE FIRE FIRE a guy that soon after. But then again, Stan Kroenke is kinda awful, so I wouldn’t put it past him.
In the meantime, he looks like he’s going to take Baker Mayfield off the scrap heap and refurbish him into being a functional QB in literal DAYS of effort. Watch, Cleveland and Carolina gave up on him, and in the next four games, McVay’s going to prove the Rams just found and rehabbed their next franchise QB.
8. Matt Eberflus, Bears: All right, we’ve left Eberflus, a first year coach alone for as long as we have because, y’know… first year coach. It’s hard to fire a guy in his first year. But when he’s 3-11 with a week until Christmas, and on a seven game losing streak, we think maybe that coach could be kicking around the top ten hottest seats. Getting a win or two in the final four games would do a lot to convince fans around Chicago that this team is trending in the right direction.
The problem with that is the Bears finish the season with a schedule of:
Bills
Lions
Vikings
Goddamn, that’s rough. That might be the hardest finish of any team in the league. Justin Fields has already put up record-breaking numbers for rushing yards by a QB with a month left (He already broke 1,000 yards rushing)… but Eberflus, a supposed “defensive guy” has the Bears 30th in scoring defense, and not exactly doing better in yards per game, particularly against the run. They kept it close versus the Eagles yesterday, but still came up short.
Should they upset one of those elite teams, it could do a lot to help Eberflus prove he’s the guy. If they don’t? Well, my math says they’d end the year on a ten game losing streak. That’s usually the job the Lions do in the NFC North, not the Bears. They just suck a moderate amount, but not completely.
7. Dennis Allen, Saints : You took over for the guy who brought a Super Bowl to New Orleans. The first rule is, “Never be the guy, who follows THE guy.” Then, you took a job where Jameis Winston was your initial QB. Your first job was, obviously, “Minimize his mistakes. His stupid, stupid mistakes.” You failed at that, and now have turned your team over to the Red Rifle, Andy Dalton, whose best years in the league were about taking a Wild Card team to the playoffs to immediately get sent home. The outlook is not even as bright of that now, in the “veteran journeyman” stage of Dalton’s career.
We were thinking New Orleans would take a step back this year, but this… yikes.
Dennis Allen has gotten the Saints off to a 5-9 start, in spite of all their talent at the skill positions and on defense. Their battery of offensive weapons are all on the shelf with injuries, and their 2023 draft prospects are irrelevant to any attempts at tanking… the Eagles own their first round pick because of the Saints trading up for WR Chris Olave… so it doesn’t look like they’re solving their hole at QB unless there’s a free agent they can snag… which isn’t traditionally the Saints’ forte.
The Saints came out of their BYE to face the Falcons, with both teams playing at this point for pride and/or draft position. New Orleans also lucked out that Atlanta were beginning the Desmond Ridder era, and their defense consumed the rookie to hold him under 100 yards passing to hang on in a 21-18 matchup.
They now travel to play the Browns on Christmas Eve, and wondering if they might not be able to steal the division away from Tom Brady and the Bucs. All four NFC South coaches are looking like their seats are warm right now, but whomever takes this godawful division and gets to the playoffs might get a pass.
6. Arthur Smith, Falcons: All right, here’s one of our true hot seats on this list. Matt Ryan is, again, gone to Indianapolis. This team was led by Marcus Mariota, for the final four games, rookie QB Desmond Ridder waiting to step in to try and prove something. Their top WR is suspended for gambling for the whole year, and their best RB (when available) is actually a WR. They have virtually no one you’ve ever heard of on the defensive side of the ball (28th in the league in defensive yards allowed), and their best player, currently, might be their kicker. And while some were crediting Smith for coaching the Falcons to hover around .500 through the first half of the season and be in contention in a pathetic NFC South without a team over that mark…
This team had a stretch of games against mediocre opponents. The Chargers, Panthers, Bears, Commanders, Steelers, Saints, all in a row, and the only win they got was against Chicago by a FG. We have had Atlanta as a coaching hot seat, but come early December, this could be a team trying to swipe a playoff spot with that schedule. But they need someone with a pulse playing on the defensive side of the ball to make that happen.
They’re sitting at 5-9, and debuted Desmond Ridder coming out of their BYE week, with a conservative game plan to protect him and prevent him from turning it over, Yeah, getting 231 yards on the ground was great, but their miserable defense couldn’t get stops against a struggling Saints offense.
Atlanta travels to Baltimore to play the Ravens, who are just trying to limp into the playoffs right now without Lamar Jackson, and that might be a team their pourous D can keep out of the end zone.