I wasn't talking about that - again, I also have mixed feelings about new Amazons popping up, though I'm much more open to it than you are. I was referring to this:
I asked about your familiarity with Perez's origin and Historia because I'm not sure how familiar you are with the established lore. I'd include the Marston comics and/or any accompanying scholarship but I've gotta cap my nerd gatekeeping somewhere
The Amazons were never Greek women, nor did they ever have husbands they lost - they were always an all-women society created by the goddesses (or in Marston's origin just Aphrodite) to combat patriarchy, though Historia's Amazons also include mortal recruits. And you've removed the Amazons' history of enslavement by and liberation from men, which is as thematically essential to WW's mythos as Krypton's destruction is to Superman's.
I do like the reincarnation idea thematically, and I like that it gives a clear reason why the Amazons look so racially and ethnically diverse. But by "I could take or leave it," I meant that I'd be fine with the Greek goddesses creating the Amazons as a new race of women without a pool of lost souls they're pulling from. I'm definitely not fine with them being ancient Greek women who lost their men and were made immortal to guard Doom's Doorway - that doesn't have any of the thematic texture that needs to be in the lore.
And regarding your larger vision of the Amazons, I'd second Alpha's question here:
With you here. My wildest dream is that they'll bring back Trevor Barnes and give him the "nerdy Wonder Woman-loving kid with old relics" origin.