Results: X-Books Awards voting 2022

[Master of Sound]

Here we go people the results of the X-Books Awards voting 2022.

You were able to vote for these the last weeks and as off today I will publish the results.

This also means you can not longer edit your submitted voted.

For those who did miss it: You can still vote HERE, but only for the yet unpublished categories.

[Master of Sound]

Favorite Ongoing Title of the Year

This year we entered the 'Destiny of X' era. Sadly enough 2022 did not include the Hellions title anymore, which had won this category of the voting contest for the last two years, neither the number two, of last year: S.W.O.R.D. We did get a few new ongoing titles and a few other remained. So which were the most popular ongoings of 2022?

NUMBER 1
X-Men Red
With 124 points, including 24 number one votes
The series that followed up after the highly appreciated SWORD series, had Storm in the role she so long deserved and she did so well. We saw the Arakki culture being explained, Magneto in a fantastic role and Sunspot finally, finally getting the spotlight and being used to his full potential that we wanted for years. The stories so well written,, the art being so suitable for the title, al this added up, made X-Men Red the winner of the most favorite ongoing title of the year.

NUMBER 2
Immortal X-Men
With 95 points, including 13 number one votes
Not a bad score for the number two. Another new title which was launched this year, focusing on the members of the Quiet Council. We had great back ground stories about some of the, other were the center of attention during the days of Judgment. Let us hope the series will get a follow up after the Sins of Sinister has been done.

NUMBER 3
X-Men
With 34 points, including twice a #1 vote
Quite a big gap between the number 3 and the two titles above, but still one of our favorites. Though not all of us thought the previous team members like Sunfire, Polris and Rogue were used to their full potential before they left, we did get a new team, including Firestar, who was voted on by the X-Men fans (though many of this board did not want her to win). We had some great stories, I like the one going back to the Vault very much. The team will move onto the next year, with very likely a new cast. Lets hope the current team will be having great adventures in the meantime.

[Master of Sound]

Least Favorite Ongoing Title
Besides loving, we also dislike some of the ongoings that have been published in 2022. Like every year, some of the voters did not want to vote for least favorites, as they wanted to stay positive, I do like that positive attitude! Last years number one was X-Force, let's see if the title did better this year........

NUMBER 1
X-Force
With 80 points, including 14 number one votes
Like last year, this is the least liked X-book at the moment. But good news, the title will continue to be published in 2023, so enough time for it to improve. Who knows, it might get better. Let at least hope the ongoing weird stuff with Beast will end, as that seems to be the main reason people dislike the book.

NUMBER 2
Marauders
With 57 points , including 8 number 1 votes
The relaunch of the Marauders into 2022 was not a great success according to the voters. The art was not liked much and the stories about the Crimson Kin and then the Treshhold were not that good written. The cast of the title was great, so let's see what the future brings us with this title.

NUMBER 3
With 32 points, including 4 number one votes
Legion of X
Somehow this new title did not do that well. I think they wanted to do to much in one title with a to large cast and to many stories at the same time. We did like the introduction of Mother Righteous, but are still in the dark who she is and why she does what she does, though we do have an idea.

[Thievery]

Can we talk about the results in this thread? If not I will edit this response out.

I honestly liked most of the miniseries better than the monthly series this year. I voted Immortal X-Men number 1, Legion of X number2, and Wolverine number 3. If I could I would probably voted at least four of the miniseries ahead of Legion of X and Wolverine, the comics that I voted second and third.

X-Men Red just isn't for me.. It's not a bad comic, it's just not for me. I don't care much for outer space stories. I can read the occasional Imperial Guard/ Shi'ar or phalanx story but that's about it. Outer space stuff just puts me to sleep just by looking at it. I can tell it's a quality comic though and if wasn't set in outer space I probably would have liked it a bit more. I followed the voting so I knew that it would win. Cograts to it and it's fans.

The main X-Men comic didn't do much for me this year.

For the results for least favorite comics I will say this:

I followed the voting so I knew that Legion of X would do poorly, but it did receive some other positive votes besides my vote for number 2 spot. It seems to be a polarizing comic. I think that people probably didn't care for some of the religeon/souls stuff in the comic but I'm not sure.

Marauders just wasn't a very good comic.

[davetvs]

#JusticeForMarauders

Y'all are letting "bad" art take you out of what is actually a really interesting book with new and newly-relevant characters that don't feel superfluous and are all getting good panel time. Marauders juggles its cast a lot better than X-Men does.

[Master of Sound]

Favorite One Shot

Some of the times we do like self contained stories. Nice 1 issue stories. Of course some are better than others of course. So which one-shot pleased you the most? Last year the Hellfire Gala was the big winner. This year we did get another Hellfire Gala, did it win again, or did another one-shot claim the number one spot?

NUMBER 1
Giant Size Thunderbird
With 40 points, including 7 number 1 votes
After so many decades, who would have thought Thunderbird John Proudstar would ever return? He was part of the ANAD team, but did not last long, as 'he had a plane to catch'. Over the years he did appear ad Dead X-Man or ghost a few times, but he is back now and started of with another fight against his long time ago nemesis Martynec

NUMBER 2
A.X.E.: X-Men
With 38 points, including 6 number 1 votes
We can say without a doubt that Judgment Day was all over the place and was actually quite well written. It also gave us multiple one-shots tying into the even and the one focusing on mainly Jean Grey was voted for many times, making it to the number two spot.

NUMBER 3
Hellfire Gala 2022
With 28 points, including four #1 votes
Last year we saw the Hellfire Gala for the first time and it had big reveals (going to Mars). This year we had another one and yes, it was widely loved again. We had the X-Men team reveal and Moira making her entrance, secretly visiting Krakoa under the skin of MJ Watson. What intrigues will we get at the gala in 2023? Can't wait to find out.

[Master of Sound]

Least Favorite One-shot

These 3 one-shots were received with little applause. Last year the Claremont Anniversary Issue was given little appreciation. This year he came back with the Gambit mini, which was way better.

This year there were not an awful not who voted in this category, so perhaps they are improving? Lets see the scores.

NUMBER 1
X-Force Annual
With 23 points, including 3 number 1 votes
This was expected ads the ongoing was also least appreciated. Let's not waste more words on it.

NUMBER 2
With 19 points, including 4 number one votes
AXE: Avengers
I honestly did not think any AXE Judgment Day titles would score bad, But apparently you guys did not like the issue that mainly focused on Tony Stark, aka Iron Man. ehhh, are we not getting some sort of crossover with him in 2023? Hope you will like that more then.


NUMBER 3
Secret X-Men
With 14 points and 2 number 1 votes.
I do believe if this was published hardcopy, it would have ended higher ranked. But this was an Marvel Unlimited series and not all here read those. The idea of a team-upo with the losers of the X-Men contest worked out great last year. But this story of a long forgotten villain trying to kidnap Gorgon, was not interesting at all. The bad art didn't help either.

[Devaishwarya]

#JusticeForMarauders

Y'all are letting "bad" art take you out of what is actually a really interesting book with new and newly-relevant characters that don't feel superfluous and are all getting good panel time. Marauders juggles its cast a lot better than X-Men does.

Fair.
Truth to tell...I would be more invested in the story if the art was better as I do like the characters of this team.
But...I'm not buying what I consider gawdfuckingawful art even if the story might (might) be interesting.

[Alex_Of_X]

Lmao Axe: Avengers is barely an X-issue, why'd it get nuked T_T

X:Red\Thunderbird winning, tho. Well deserved!

[davetvs]

Fair.
Truth to tell...I would be more invested in the story if the art was better as I do like the characters of this team.
But...I'm not buying what I consider gawdfuckingawful art even if the story might (might) be interesting.

For sure, enough people have complained about the art that it's clearly hampering sales and excitement for the book. I just think it's unfortunate, because the plot with Threshold is literally a BobbysWorld comment come to life, and as much as we complain about the lack of actual diversity in the X-Characters who get the spotlight, this book stars Bishop, Kitty, Kwannon, Daken, Aurora, Somnus, Tempo, and Cassandra Nova. That's an incredibly diverse lineup and if we did the math, probably the most diverse lineup of the current slate of books. The fact that Daken is a bisexual in a heterosexual relationship on the team with his ex-boyfriend AND current girlfriend, and they all get along, is honestly progressive as ****.

[Steroid]

Fair.
Truth to tell...I would be more invested in the story if the art was better as I do like the characters of this team.
But...I'm not buying what I consider gawdfuckingawful art even if the story might (might) be interesting.

Fully admit that the art is what keeps me from reading the book. IMO it's too much of a hindrance for me to even consider paying to look at no matter how interesting the story may be.

[jwatson]

#JusticeForMarauders

Y'all are letting "bad" art take you out of what is actually a really interesting book with new and newly-relevant characters that don't feel superfluous and are all getting good panel time. Marauders juggles its cast a lot better than X-Men does.

seconded. I may like the art of marauders but it's very easy to see other people's problem with it. It's overtly stylized and can be confusing since some of the characters look the same in costume. I mean couldn't say one criticism of the art wasn't valid or was a reach.

[Uncanny X-Man]

Favorite Ongoing Title of the Year

This year we entered the 'Destiny of X' era. Sadly enough 2022 did not include the Hellions title anymore, which had won this category of the voting contest for the last two years, neither the number two, of last year: S.W.O.R.D. We did get a few new ongoing titles and a few other remained. So which were the most popular ongoings of 2022?

NUMBER 1
X-Men Red
With 124 points, including 24 number one votes
The series that followed up after the highly appreciated SWORD series, had Storm in the role she so long deserved and she did so well. We saw the Arakki culture being explained, Magneto in a fantastic role and Sunspot finally, finally getting the spotlight and being used to his full potential that we wanted for years. The stories so well written,, the art being so suitable for the title, al this added up, made X-Men Red the winner of the most favorite ongoing title of the year.

NUMBER 2
Immortal X-Men
With 95 points, including 13 number one votes
Not a bad score for the number two. Another new title which was launched this year, focusing on the members of the Quiet Council. We had great back ground stories about some of the, other were the center of attention during the days of Judgment. Let us hope the series will get a follow up after the Sins of Sinister has been done.

NUMBER 3
X-Men
With 34 points, including twice a #1 vote
Quite a big gap between the number 3 and the two titles above, but still one of our favorites. Though not all of us thought the previous team members like Sunfire, Polris and Rogue were used to their full potential before they left, we did get a new team, including Firestar, who was voted on by the X-Men fans (though many of this board did not want her to win). We had some great stories, I like the one going back to the Vault very much. The team will move onto the next year, with very likely a new cast. Lets hope the current team will be having great adventures in the meantime.

I'm happy with these results which also reflect how I have voted and how I feel about these books. Red at number 1 but Immortal being a close second... I think Ewing has an edge and is one of the best writers working at Marvel at the moment, but Gillen is no slouch either and all of his work on the X-Men has been excellent so far.

Gerry Duggan's X-Men is a distant third, is almost always pretty enjoyable overall with a few bits striving towards brilliance. All in all, the core books are the strongest they've been in a loooong time.