I'm with you on loving the JMS\JRJR stretch. Deodato...I'll honestly take him over Garney. Imho Garney's pencils on Civil War and Black in Black are middling. I think he's trying to go for an in-between of JRJR and Deodato, and it ends up looking like Adam Kubert on an off day. Garney's much crisper now, on Daredevil and Thor.
Also Back in Black feels off to me? I feel like JMS is going for badassery aka the Crow, but lacking distinct visuals, it's just a lot of dollar store Jason Bourne followed by a bloody jail beatdown. Spidey beats up the Kingpin, but it's neither cool-looking, nor really heroic, since Fisk still got what he wanted